Skip to content
New issue

Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.

By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.

Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account

Minor fixes and improvements #52

Open
wants to merge 3 commits into
base: master
Choose a base branch
from

Conversation

mstock
Copy link

@mstock mstock commented Jul 16, 2021

While working on the intro/outro for the SotM 2021 videos, I noticed some minor issues when rendering the videos. Some of these already had GitHub issues (which should be referenced from the commits in this PR) that should also get fixed by these changes.

Please note that the last two commits make use of features that are only available in more recent Inkscape versions, i.e. the version from e.g. Debian Buster is too old for this, the Backport should work though.

@saerdnaer saerdnaer requested a review from derchrisuk July 26, 2021 19:21
@saerdnaer
Copy link
Member

@derchrisuk willst du da noch drüber schauen oder kann ich das so mergen?

@derchrisuk
Copy link
Member

derchrisuk commented Nov 15, 2021

Ich schau mir das gerade an.
Aktuell failed der PR aber bei mir:

./make.py fiffkon21/ --id 174 --skip ouit
inkscape exitted with error
Entity: line 25: parser error : expected '>'
</
  ^
Entity: line 25: parser error : Opening and ending tag mismatch: svg line 1 and unparseable
</
  ^
Background RRGGBBAA: ffffff00
Area 0:0:1920:1080 exported to 1920 x 1080 pixels (96 dpi)

@mstock
Copy link
Author

mstock commented Nov 15, 2021

Lustigerweise scheint zumindest bei mir trotzdem ein abspielbares Intro und Outro generiert zu werden, trotz der ganzen Fehler. Ich hab noch einen Commit auf den Branch gepusht, der das Problem mit der Fehlermeldung/Warnung bei mir behoben hat. Momentan vermute ich da tatsaechlich einen Bug in Inkscape, wenn man ein SVG mit UTF-8-Codierung per Pipe uebergibt. Wandelt man dieses z.B. per xmllint vorher nach ASCII um, dann gibt's keine Fehlermeldung (was quasi dem entspricht, was mein letzter Commit macht) und die Ausgabe sieht fuer mich identisch aus. Alternativ kann man auch nach dem schliessenden </svg> einfach noch ein paar Leerzeilen einfuegen, dann funktioniert es auch... Ich mach da wahrscheinlich bei Inkscape noch einen Bugreport, Ich hab da bei Inkscape mal einen Bugreport gemacht, reproduzieren kann ich das auch mit Version 1.1.1. aus Debian Sid noch, bestehende Bugreports dazu habe ich nicht gefunden.

Was mir beim Testen uebrigens nebenbei noch aufgefallen ist: In den beiden fiffkon21-SVG-Dateien steht Selbsbestimmung, auf deren Website Selbstbestimmung (d.h. mit t beim Selbst).

mstock added 3 commits August 27, 2022 15:34
This was already suggested in voc#22. In addition to potentially being a
little more efficient, this also avoids the problem of files referenced
from the SVG not being found, since the SVG is now rendered while in the
artwork directory, so relative paths inside the SVG are still correct.

Please note that the pipe functionality of Inkscape requires a relatively
new version of Inkscape, i.e. the version from Debian Buster is not
sufficient (the Buster backport from Debian should be though).

Unfortunately, the same does not work when using ImageMagick, since it
seems like they use different delegates/libraries to render the SVG based
on how it is passed, i.e. when passed as file, it got rendered with
Inkscape on my machine, when passing it as blob, it seemed to be some
internal library or another delegate which did not seem to support the
same feature set as Inkscape, which resulted in inferior output. Therefore,
a temporary file is still used for ImageMagick. However, the issue of
included images that could be solved for Inkscape with these changes
still persists, since at least when using the Inkscape delegate,
ImageMagick seems to create a temporary symbolic link in /tmp, which
prevents that the Inkscape delegate finds included images.
It seems that when processing a SVG file passed via a pipe, Inkscape emits
errors/warnings about an XML parser error if the SVG file is UTF-8
encoded. It still does seem to successfully process the SVG file and
generates the expected output, however, these messages are at least
confusing. Not passing the encoding parameter to etree.tostring() makes
it output ASCII with non-ASCII characters encoded as XML entities, so this
can then be correctly parsed again, and this does not seem to 'confuse'
Inkscape.
… output

Since videos with translations appear to require at least as many audio
streams in the intro/outro as there are audio streams in the main video,
this allows to create intro/outro files for videos with more than one
translation (so far, the code already created 2 streams).
@mstock mstock force-pushed the minor-fixes-and-improvements branch from b165be1 to af310d7 Compare August 27, 2022 19:24
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment
Labels
None yet
Projects
None yet
Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

3 participants