Skip to content

duckplyr 1.0.0 #724

New issue

Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.

By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.

Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account

Open
wants to merge 96 commits into
base: main
Choose a base branch
from
Open
Show file tree
Hide file tree
Changes from all commits
Commits
Show all changes
96 commits
Select commit Hold shift + click to select a range
96861b7
duckplyr 1.0.0
maelle Feb 11, 2025
5b2b472
restructure, better to explain some things first?!
maelle Feb 11, 2025
97739a8
oops
maelle Feb 11, 2025
1d80f56
evaluate...
maelle Feb 11, 2025
11e21c1
format
maelle Feb 11, 2025
eb09f2b
link
maelle Feb 11, 2025
44b7c66
tweak
maelle Feb 11, 2025
20b6a6e
fix mistake
maelle Feb 11, 2025
4ccfa70
link issue
maelle Feb 11, 2025
692b390
thanks @krlmlr
maelle Feb 11, 2025
0df0d53
explicitly mention data size
maelle Feb 11, 2025
4251569
fully compatible
maelle Feb 11, 2025
e30f959
add ref for DuckDB
maelle Feb 11, 2025
1cec2cb
compare to other backends
maelle Feb 11, 2025
b276db4
rm prudence @krlmlr
maelle Feb 11, 2025
7c92ddb
fallbacks
maelle Feb 11, 2025
d8aca67
link to docs
maelle Feb 11, 2025
480551b
more details here
maelle Feb 11, 2025
6adf074
links
maelle Feb 11, 2025
c955826
isn't this a goal too @krlmlr
maelle Feb 11, 2025
1c5153f
link
maelle Feb 11, 2025
78ee84b
more promises :sweat_smile:
maelle Feb 11, 2025
1b55a30
add thumbnail-wd
maelle Feb 11, 2025
ae87276
add thumbnail-sq
maelle Feb 11, 2025
ae8c8e6
check thumbnail things
maelle Feb 11, 2025
7661ad3
lol
maelle Feb 11, 2025
48eba60
phrasing
maelle Feb 11, 2025
8b6d0bd
Space at EOL
krlmlr Feb 13, 2025
e25fb07
Sentence
krlmlr Feb 13, 2025
a0b9b39
FIXME
krlmlr Feb 13, 2025
b90e8af
Shorten
krlmlr Feb 13, 2025
5ac6f6e
Verbose link
krlmlr Feb 13, 2025
14ec2f6
Not dying on this particular hill here
krlmlr Feb 13, 2025
b9a277a
Tweak query, let's see
krlmlr Feb 13, 2025
5762c0a
Prune
krlmlr Feb 13, 2025
6aaf953
This works
krlmlr Feb 13, 2025
f847736
Tweak narrative
krlmlr Feb 13, 2025
c78073f
Choose pivoting as an important op not yet supported
krlmlr Feb 13, 2025
1f898c0
Link style
krlmlr Feb 13, 2025
5a1f22c
aeolus
krlmlr Feb 13, 2025
2b4b421
Help
krlmlr Feb 13, 2025
d97b031
Exclude maintainers
krlmlr Feb 13, 2025
4be5ea9
Thanks
krlmlr Feb 13, 2025
f344b9f
Link
krlmlr Feb 13, 2025
a13315a
Restore narrative
krlmlr Feb 13, 2025
ad9825f
Add vignette link
krlmlr Feb 13, 2025
a734638
FIXME
krlmlr Feb 13, 2025
fc8122d
Date
krlmlr Feb 13, 2025
3211710
Why bother
krlmlr Feb 13, 2025
eea955a
Level
krlmlr Feb 13, 2025
4a20ca3
Move
krlmlr Feb 13, 2025
f5e4a38
Detail
krlmlr Feb 13, 2025
20dff03
TBC
krlmlr Feb 13, 2025
f231c68
Merge pull request #1 from krlmlr/duckplyr-post-krlmlr
maelle Feb 13, 2025
49b4f8b
kill your babies
maelle Feb 13, 2025
6b84b25
.
maelle Feb 13, 2025
452d5f2
typo
maelle Feb 13, 2025
21c2b74
use suggestion without repeating backend that's in the sentence right…
maelle Feb 20, 2025
a21daa5
fix
maelle Feb 20, 2025
9022d7f
specific
maelle Feb 20, 2025
f0563c0
start tweaking
maelle Feb 20, 2025
88846a3
weave benchmark in?
maelle Feb 20, 2025
17cdfc3
just rm
maelle Feb 20, 2025
9e0e496
rm ellipsis + comment on benchmark
maelle Feb 20, 2025
a5ac341
port majority of Kirill's edits
maelle Feb 20, 2025
36a93cb
fix phrasing
maelle Feb 20, 2025
4f88bbd
hide it for real
maelle Feb 20, 2025
ad8866a
Apply suggestions from code review
maelle Feb 21, 2025
beee540
un-hide
maelle Feb 21, 2025
5fe00ac
add this edit of @krlmlr's
maelle Feb 21, 2025
a186621
one fixme
maelle Feb 21, 2025
a994038
new section
maelle Feb 21, 2025
ac86b3a
rephrase
maelle Feb 21, 2025
4d6fa0d
typo
maelle Feb 21, 2025
0582a15
make it work :sweat_smile:
maelle Feb 21, 2025
735e9d9
Recreate environment and re-render
krlmlr Feb 21, 2025
217144a
Bold face
krlmlr Feb 22, 2025
dc07389
"small results processed seamlessly with dplyr" is the main goal of p…
krlmlr Feb 21, 2025
663eda2
Declutter
krlmlr Feb 21, 2025
dd9d20d
Space
krlmlr Feb 21, 2025
0008ac8
Move
krlmlr Feb 21, 2025
ea3fda0
methods_restore() needed only later
krlmlr Feb 21, 2025
9128e16
Wrap
krlmlr Feb 21, 2025
eaee543
Wording
krlmlr Feb 21, 2025
931fd45
lineitem_tbl
krlmlr Feb 21, 2025
5bb1a84
Keep it simple
krlmlr Feb 21, 2025
78729ac
Caveat
krlmlr Feb 21, 2025
0ef4ace
Stress
krlmlr Feb 21, 2025
0f23a74
Use function from the beginning
krlmlr Feb 22, 2025
236d793
Prune
krlmlr Feb 22, 2025
5bc98a6
Section
krlmlr Feb 22, 2025
cf61e47
Explicit verbosity
krlmlr Feb 22, 2025
bfac020
Render
krlmlr Feb 22, 2025
d0ed8f9
Merge branch 'main' into duckplyr-post
krlmlr Feb 23, 2025
51931cb
Final edits
krlmlr Feb 23, 2025
1ddb0e1
Paragraph and comments
krlmlr Feb 23, 2025
File filter

Filter by extension

Filter by extension

Conversations
Failed to load comments.
Loading
Jump to
Jump to file
Failed to load files.
Loading
Diff view
Diff view
241 changes: 241 additions & 0 deletions content/blog/duckplyr-1-0-0/index.Rmd
Original file line number Diff line number Diff line change
@@ -0,0 +1,241 @@
---
output: hugodown::hugo_document

slug: duckplyr-1-0-0
title: duckplyr fully joins the tidyverse!
date: 2025-02-13
author: Kirill Müller and Maëlle Salmon
description: >
duckplyr 1.0.0 is on CRAN and part of the tidyverse!
Copy link
Member

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

The reason will be displayed to describe this comment to others. Learn more.

Working on that part, duckdb 1.2.0 is about to be released tomorrow.

A drop-in replacement for dplyr, powered by DuckDB for speed.
It is the most dplyr-like of dplyr backends.

photo:
url: https://www.pexels.com/photo/a-mallard-duck-on-water-6918877/
author: Kiril Gruev

# one of: "deep-dive", "learn", "package", "programming", "roundup", or "other"
categories: [package]
tags:
- duckplyr
- dplyr
- tidyverse
---

```{r include = FALSE}
options(
pillar.min_title_chars = 20,
pillar.max_footer_lines = 7,
pillar.bold = TRUE
)
```


We're very chuffed to announce the release of [duckplyr](https://duckplyr.tidyverse.org) 1.0.0.
This is a new dplyr backend powered by [DuckDB](https://duckdb.org/), a fast in-memory analytical database system[^duckdb].
It joins the rank of dplyr backends together with [dtplyr](https://dtplyr.tidyverse.org) and [dbplyr](https://dbplyr.tidyverse.org).
You can install it from CRAN with:

```{r, eval = FALSE}
install.packages("duckplyr")
Copy link
Member

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

The reason will be displayed to describe this comment to others. Learn more.

With tidyverse/tidyverse#346, we can also install.packages("tidyverse") .

Copy link
Contributor Author

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

The reason will be displayed to describe this comment to others. Learn more.

Right, but won't the post be published before the PR is merged and the tidyverse package is released on CRAN?

```

This article shows how duckplyr can be used instead of dplyr with data of different size for faster computation, explain how you can help improve the package, and share a selection of further resources.

## A drop-in replacement for dplyr

Imagine you have to wrangle a huge dataset.
Here we generate one using the [data generator from the TPC-H benchmark](https://duckdb.org/2024/04/02/duckplyr.html#benchmark-tpc-h-q1).

```{r}
lineitem_tbl <- duckdb:::sql("INSTALL tpch; LOAD tpch; CALL dbgen(sf=1); FROM lineitem;")
lineitem_tbl <- tibble::as_tibble(lineitem_tbl)
dplyr::glimpse(lineitem_tbl)
```

We could transform the data using dplyr but we could also transform it using a tool that'll scale well to ever larger data: duckplyr.
The duckplyr package is a _drop-in replacement for dplyr_ that uses _DuckDB for speed_.
Copy link
Member

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

The reason will be displayed to describe this comment to others. Learn more.

I think you need a sentence or two here as to why it's needed compared to dbplyr.

Copy link
Member

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

The reason will be displayed to describe this comment to others. Learn more.

Done below: https://github.com/tidyverse/tidyverse.org/pull/724/files#diff-30be2863e4e092b08c7c1ad595164bec2f424a02f175c56e32f85d3475559a94R102-R104

Like with other dplyr backends like dtplyr and dbplyr, duckplyr allows you to get faster results without learning a different syntax.
Unlike other dplyr backends, duckplyr does not require you to change existing code or learn specific idiosyncracies.
Not only is the syntax the same, the semantics are too!

You can simply _drop_ duckplyr into your pipeline by loading it, then computations will be efficiently carried out by DuckDB.

[^duckdb]: If you haven't heard about it, you can watch [Hannes Mühleisen's keynote at posit::conf(2024)](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GELhdezYmP0&feature=youtu.be).

Below, we express the standard "TPC-H benchmark query 1" in dplyr syntax, but execute it with duckplyr.
We use a function because this code is reused throughout the article.

```{r include=FALSE}
options(conflicts.policy = list(warn = FALSE))
```


```{r}
library(conflicted)
library(duckplyr)
conflict_prefer("filter", "dplyr", quiet = TRUE)

tpch_dplyr <- function(lineitem) {
lineitem |>
filter(l_shipdate <= !!as.Date("1998-09-02")) |>
summarise(
sum_qty = sum(l_quantity),
sum_base_price = sum(l_extendedprice),
sum_disc_price = sum(l_extendedprice * (1 - l_discount)),
sum_charge = sum(l_extendedprice * (1 - l_discount) * (1 + l_tax)),
avg_qty = mean(l_quantity),
avg_price = mean(l_extendedprice),
avg_disc = mean(l_discount),
count_order = n(),
.by = c(l_returnflag, l_linestatus)
) |>
arrange(l_returnflag, l_linestatus)
}

tpch_dplyr(lineitem_tbl)
```

Like with other dplyr backends like dtplyr and dbplyr, duckplyr allows you to get faster results without learning a different syntax.
Unlike other dplyr backends, duckplyr does not require you to change existing code or learn specific idiosyncrasies.
Not only is the syntax the same, the semantics are too!

Start using duckplyr today by attaching it and running your existing dplyr code.
Many operations will be carried out with DuckDB, faster than with dplyr.
The duckplyr package is fully compatible with dplyr: if an operation cannot be carried out with DuckDB, it is automatically outsourced to dplyr.
Over time, we expect fewer and fewer fallbacks to dplyr to be needed.


## How to use duckplyr

To _replace_ dplyr with duckplyr, you can:

- Load duckplyr and then keep your pipeline as is. Calling `library(duckplyr)` overwrites dplyr methods, enabling duckplyr for the entire session no matter how data.frames are created.
This is shown in the example above.

- Create individual "duck frames" using _conversion functions_ like `duckdb_tibble()` or `as_duckdb_tibble()`, or _ingestion functions_ like `read_csv_duckdb()`.


In both cases, the data manipulation pipeline uses the exact same syntax as a dplyr pipeline, with the exact same semantics.
The duckplyr package performs the computation using DuckDB.

```{r}
out <- lineitem_tbl |>
duckplyr::as_duckdb_tibble() |>
tpch_dplyr()

out
```


For programming, the resulting object is indistinguishable from a regular tibble, except for the additional class.


```{r}
typeof(out)
class(out)
out$count_order
```

The result could also be computed to a file.

```{r}
csv_file <- withr::local_tempfile()
compute_csv(out, csv_file)
fs::file_size(csv_file)
```

Operations not yet supported by duckplyr are automatically outsourced to dplyr.
For instance, filtering on grouped data is not supported yet, still it works thanks to the fallback mechanism.
By default, the fallback is silent.
Here, we make it visible by setting an environment variable.

```{r}
Sys.setenv(DUCKPLYR_FALLBACK_INFO = TRUE)

lineitem_tbl |>
duckplyr::as_duckdb_tibble() |>
filter(l_quantity == max(l_quantity), .by = c(l_returnflag, l_linestatus))
Copy link
Member

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

The reason will be displayed to describe this comment to others. Learn more.

I wonder why you're seeing the message here in the rendered output. Have you set an environment variable?

Copy link
Contributor Author

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

The reason will be displayed to describe this comment to others. Learn more.

I'm not sure but it's better, I wanted to show the message and was puzzled when it didn't show up. It's nice to show one gets a message I think?

Copy link
Contributor Author

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

The reason will be displayed to describe this comment to others. Learn more.

I'll knit again once the new version is on CRAN, this way the message won't have the typo (tidyverse/duckplyr#611)

```


## Benchmark

duckplyr is often much faster than dplyr.
The comparison below is done in a fresh R session where dplyr is attached but duckplyr is not.

```{r include = FALSE}
# Undo the effect of library(duckplyr)
methods_restore()
```

```r
# Restart R
library(dplyr)

tpch_dplyr <- function ...
```

We use `tpch_dplyr()` as defined above to run the query with dplyr.
The function that runs it with duckplyr only wraps the input data in a duck frame and forwards it to the dplyr function.
The `collect()` at the end is required only for this benchmark to ensure fairness.[^collect]

[^collect]: If omitted, the results would be unchanged but the measurements would be wrong. The computation would then be triggered by the check. See `vignette("prudence")` for details.

```{r}
tpch_duckplyr <- function(lineitem) {
lineitem |>
duckplyr::as_duckdb_tibble() |>
tpch_dplyr() |>
collect()
}
```

And now we compare the two:

```{r}
bench::mark(
tpch_dplyr(lineitem_tbl),
tpch_duckplyr(lineitem_tbl),
check = ~ all.equal(.x, .y, tolerance = 1e-10)
)
```

In this example, the pipeline run with duckplyr is clearly faster than the pipeline run with dplyr.
It also appears to use much less memory, but this is misleading: DuckDB uses memory outside of R's memory management, so the memory usage is not visible to R.

## Data larger than memory

With datasets that approach or surpass the size of your machine's RAM, you want:

- input data in an efficient format, like Parquet files, which duckplyr allows thanks to its ingestion functions like `read_parquet_duckdb()`;
- efficient computation, which duckplyr provides via DuckDB's holistic optimization, without having to adapt your code;
- large results to not clutter your memory by dumping them to files using [`compute_parquet()`](https://duckplyr.tidyverse.org/reference/compute_parquet.html) or [`compute_csv()`](https://duckplyr.tidyverse.org/reference/compute_csv.html);
- small results processed seamlessly with dplyr, using all verbs and functions.

This workflow is fully supported by duckplyr.
See [`vignette("large")`](https://duckplyr.tidyverse.org/articles/large.html) for a walkthrough and more details.

## Help us improve duckplyr!

Our goals for future development of duckplyr include:

- Enabling users to provide [custom translations](https://github.com/tidyverse/duckplyr/issues/158) of dplyr functionality;
- Making it easier to contribute code to duckplyr;
- Supporting more dplyr and tidyr functionality natively in DuckDB.

You can help!

- Please report any issues, especially regarding unknown incompabilities. See [`vignette("limits")`](https://duckplyr.tidyverse.org/articles/limits.html).
- Contribute to the codebase after reading duckplyr's [contributing guide](https://duckplyr.tidyverse.org/CONTRIBUTING.html).
- Turn on telemetry to help us hear about the most frequent fallbacks so we can prioritize working on the corresponding missing dplyr translation. See [`vignette("telemetry")`](https://duckplyr.tidyverse.org/articles/telemetry.html) and the [`duckplyr::fallback_sitrep()`](https://duckplyr.tidyverse.org/reference/fallback.html) function.

## Additional resources

Eager to learn more about duckplyr -- beside by trying it out yourself?
The pkgdown website of duckplyr features several [articles](https://duckplyr.tidyverse.org/articles/).
Furthermore, the blog post ["duckplyr: dplyr Powered by DuckDB"](https://duckdb.org/2024/04/02/duckplyr.html) by Hannes Mühleisen provides some context on duckplyr including its inner workings, as also seen in a [section](https://blog.r-hub.io/2025/02/13/lazy-meanings/#duckplyr-lazy-evaluation-and-prudence) of the R-hub blog post ["Lazy introduction to laziness in R"](https://blog.r-hub.io/2025/02/13/lazy-meanings/) by Maëlle Salmon, Athanasia Mo Mowinckel and Hannah Frick.

## Acknowledgements

A big thanks to all folks who filed issues, created PRs and generally helped to improve duckplyr and its workhorse [duckdb](https://r.duckdb.org/)!

[&#x0040;adamschwing](https://github.com/adamschwing), [&#x0040;alejandrohagan](https://github.com/alejandrohagan), [&#x0040;andreranza](https://github.com/andreranza), [&#x0040;apalacio9502](https://github.com/apalacio9502), [&#x0040;apsteinmetz](https://github.com/apsteinmetz), [&#x0040;barracuda156](https://github.com/barracuda156), [&#x0040;beniaminogreen](https://github.com/beniaminogreen), [&#x0040;bob-rietveld](https://github.com/bob-rietveld), [&#x0040;brichards920](https://github.com/brichards920), [&#x0040;cboettig](https://github.com/cboettig), [&#x0040;davidjayjackson](https://github.com/davidjayjackson), [&#x0040;DavisVaughan](https://github.com/DavisVaughan), [&#x0040;Ed2uiz](https://github.com/Ed2uiz), [&#x0040;eitsupi](https://github.com/eitsupi), [&#x0040;era127](https://github.com/era127), [&#x0040;etiennebacher](https://github.com/etiennebacher), [&#x0040;eutwt](https://github.com/eutwt), [&#x0040;fmichonneau](https://github.com/fmichonneau), [&#x0040;hadley](https://github.com/hadley), [&#x0040;hannes](https://github.com/hannes), [&#x0040;hawkfish](https://github.com/hawkfish), [&#x0040;IndrajeetPatil](https://github.com/IndrajeetPatil), [&#x0040;JanSulavik](https://github.com/JanSulavik), [&#x0040;JavOrraca](https://github.com/JavOrraca), [&#x0040;jeroen](https://github.com/jeroen), [&#x0040;jhk0530](https://github.com/jhk0530), [&#x0040;joakimlinde](https://github.com/joakimlinde), [&#x0040;JosiahParry](https://github.com/JosiahParry), [&#x0040;kevbaer](https://github.com/kevbaer), [&#x0040;larry77](https://github.com/larry77), [&#x0040;lnkuiper](https://github.com/lnkuiper), [&#x0040;lorenzwalthert](https://github.com/lorenzwalthert), [&#x0040;lschneiderbauer](https://github.com/lschneiderbauer), [&#x0040;luisDVA](https://github.com/luisDVA), [&#x0040;math-mcshane](https://github.com/math-mcshane), [&#x0040;meersel](https://github.com/meersel), [&#x0040;multimeric](https://github.com/multimeric), [&#x0040;mytarmail](https://github.com/mytarmail), [&#x0040;nicki-dese](https://github.com/nicki-dese), [&#x0040;PMassicotte](https://github.com/PMassicotte), [&#x0040;prasundutta87](https://github.com/prasundutta87), [&#x0040;rafapereirabr](https://github.com/rafapereirabr), [&#x0040;Robinlovelace](https://github.com/Robinlovelace), [&#x0040;romainfrancois](https://github.com/romainfrancois), [&#x0040;sparrow925](https://github.com/sparrow925), [&#x0040;stefanlinner](https://github.com/stefanlinner), [&#x0040;szarnyasg](https://github.com/szarnyasg), [&#x0040;thomasp85](https://github.com/thomasp85), [&#x0040;TimTaylor](https://github.com/TimTaylor), [&#x0040;Tmonster](https://github.com/Tmonster), [&#x0040;toppyy](https://github.com/toppyy), [&#x0040;wibeasley](https://github.com/wibeasley), [&#x0040;yjunechoe](https://github.com/yjunechoe), [&#x0040;ywhcuhk](https://github.com/ywhcuhk), [&#x0040;zhjx19](https://github.com/zhjx19), [&#x0040;ablack3](https://github.com/ablack3), [&#x0040;actuarial-lonewolf](https://github.com/actuarial-lonewolf), [&#x0040;ajdamico](https://github.com/ajdamico), [&#x0040;amirmazmi](https://github.com/amirmazmi), [&#x0040;anderson461123](https://github.com/anderson461123), [&#x0040;andrewGhazi](https://github.com/andrewGhazi), [&#x0040;Antonov548](https://github.com/Antonov548), [&#x0040;appiehappie999](https://github.com/appiehappie999), [&#x0040;ArthurAndrews](https://github.com/ArthurAndrews), [&#x0040;arthurgailes](https://github.com/arthurgailes), [&#x0040;babaknaimi](https://github.com/babaknaimi), [&#x0040;bcaradima](https://github.com/bcaradima), [&#x0040;bdforbes](https://github.com/bdforbes), [&#x0040;bergest](https://github.com/bergest), [&#x0040;bill-ash](https://github.com/bill-ash), [&#x0040;BorgeJorge](https://github.com/BorgeJorge), [&#x0040;brianmsm](https://github.com/brianmsm), [&#x0040;chainsawriot](https://github.com/chainsawriot), [&#x0040;ckarnes](https://github.com/ckarnes), [&#x0040;clementlefevre](https://github.com/clementlefevre), [&#x0040;cregouby](https://github.com/cregouby), [&#x0040;cy-james-lee](https://github.com/cy-james-lee), [&#x0040;daranzolin](https://github.com/daranzolin), [&#x0040;david-cortes](https://github.com/david-cortes), [&#x0040;DavZim](https://github.com/DavZim), [&#x0040;denis-or](https://github.com/denis-or), [&#x0040;developertest1234](https://github.com/developertest1234), [&#x0040;dicorynia](https://github.com/dicorynia), [&#x0040;dsolito](https://github.com/dsolito), [&#x0040;e-kotov](https://github.com/e-kotov), [&#x0040;EAVWing](https://github.com/EAVWing), [&#x0040;eddelbuettel](https://github.com/eddelbuettel), [&#x0040;edward-burn](https://github.com/edward-burn), [&#x0040;elefeint](https://github.com/elefeint), [&#x0040;eli-daniels](https://github.com/eli-daniels), [&#x0040;elysabethpc](https://github.com/elysabethpc), [&#x0040;erikvona](https://github.com/erikvona), [&#x0040;florisvdh](https://github.com/florisvdh), [&#x0040;gaborcsardi](https://github.com/gaborcsardi), [&#x0040;ggrothendieck](https://github.com/ggrothendieck), [&#x0040;hdmm3](https://github.com/hdmm3), [&#x0040;hope-data-science](https://github.com/hope-data-science), [&#x0040;IoannaNika](https://github.com/IoannaNika), [&#x0040;jabrown-aepenergy](https://github.com/jabrown-aepenergy), [&#x0040;JamesLMacAulay](https://github.com/JamesLMacAulay), [&#x0040;jangorecki](https://github.com/jangorecki), [&#x0040;javierlenzi](https://github.com/javierlenzi), [&#x0040;Joe-Heffer-Shef](https://github.com/Joe-Heffer-Shef), [&#x0040;kalibera](https://github.com/kalibera), [&#x0040;lboller-pwbm](https://github.com/lboller-pwbm), [&#x0040;lgaborini](https://github.com/lgaborini), [&#x0040;m-muecke](https://github.com/m-muecke), [&#x0040;meztez](https://github.com/meztez), [&#x0040;mgirlich](https://github.com/mgirlich), [&#x0040;mtmorgan](https://github.com/mtmorgan), [&#x0040;nassuphis](https://github.com/nassuphis), [&#x0040;nbc](https://github.com/nbc), [&#x0040;olivroy](https://github.com/olivroy), [&#x0040;pdet](https://github.com/pdet), [&#x0040;phdjsep](https://github.com/phdjsep), [&#x0040;pierre-lamarche](https://github.com/pierre-lamarche), [&#x0040;r2evans](https://github.com/r2evans), [&#x0040;ran-codes](https://github.com/ran-codes), [&#x0040;rplsmn](https://github.com/rplsmn), [&#x0040;Saarialho](https://github.com/Saarialho), [&#x0040;SimonCoulombe](https://github.com/SimonCoulombe), [&#x0040;tau31](https://github.com/tau31), [&#x0040;thohan88](https://github.com/thohan88), [&#x0040;ThomasSoeiro](https://github.com/ThomasSoeiro), [&#x0040;timothygmitchell](https://github.com/timothygmitchell), [&#x0040;vincentarelbundock](https://github.com/vincentarelbundock), [&#x0040;VincentGuyader](https://github.com/VincentGuyader), [&#x0040;wlangera](https://github.com/wlangera), [&#x0040;xbasics](https://github.com/xbasics), [&#x0040;xiaodaigh](https://github.com/xiaodaigh), [&#x0040;xtimbeau](https://github.com/xtimbeau), [&#x0040;yng-me](https://github.com/yng-me), [&#x0040;Yousuf28](https://github.com/Yousuf28), [&#x0040;yutannihilation](https://github.com/yutannihilation), and [&#x0040;zcatav](https://github.com/zcatav)

Special thanks to Joe Thorley ([&#x0040;joethorley](https://github.com/joethorley)) for help with choosing the right words.
Loading