Skip to content

research(ehrhart-cube-proven-oq-02): S8 STATE-SYNC — nextSteps cleanup + nextAction realignment + sessions/ bootstrap + knowledge.md handoff (doc-only)#19637

Merged
rjwalters merged 1 commit into
mainfrom
research/researcher-4-ehrhart-cube-oq02-s1429Z
May 16, 2026
Merged

research(ehrhart-cube-proven-oq-02): S8 STATE-SYNC — nextSteps cleanup + nextAction realignment + sessions/ bootstrap + knowledge.md handoff (doc-only)#19637
rjwalters merged 1 commit into
mainfrom
research/researcher-4-ehrhart-cube-oq02-s1429Z

Conversation

@rjwalters
Copy link
Copy Markdown
Owner

Summary

The 2026-05-13/14 STATE-SYNC (PR #18953) was a thorough top-level
refresh (top-level JSON phase/status/progressSummary + leanFiles[0]
counts to S7 outcome; removed a duplicate stale S6 block). S8 absorbs
the residual drift it did not explicitly scope:

  • knowledge.nextSteps 3 → 4 items: drop 2 already-discharged (S7
    slicing-prototype DONE in PR research(ehrhart-cube-proven-oq-02): S7 — close crossBall_card via slicing decomposition (build verified) #17362; S8 sorryCount=0/status=verified
    DONE per JSON top-level); keep S9 reframed as "dedicated-slug
    candidate" for central Delannoy upstream Mathlib contribution; add 3
    cosmetic follow-ups from state.md "Follow-Up (optional,
    post-completion)" list (set/refine cosmetic refactor; le_or_lt
    deprecation warning; permutohedron/hypersimplex/flow-polytope
    dedicated-slug candidates).
  • currentState.nextAction rewritten to match state.md Follow-Up +
    cross-reference S8 memo §3 for knowledge.md staleness handoff.
  • sessions/ subdirectory bootstrapped with new S8 memo (~218 LOC, 8
    sections). The existing session-5-slicing-spec.md is LEFT IN PLACE
    at the slug-dir root (do not git-mv; more invasive than S8 scope).
  • knowledge.md line ~10 ("Two sorries remain") factual staleness
    flagged in S8 memo §3 as a ready-to-paste diff for downstream
    mechanic/researcher; not edited here (knowledge.md is research/domain
    territory, not STATE-SYNC territory).

3 files, conflict-free (no open PRs for this slug; PR #17030 surfaced
by search is for cantor-diagonalization-oq-04-oq-01 via cross-ref):

  • research/problems/<slug>/state.md (head + S8 entry)
  • src/data/research/problems/<slug>.json (5 fields: iteration/focus/nextAction/nextSteps/lastUpdate)
  • research/problems/<slug>/sessions/2026-05-16-s8-state-sync-nextsteps-cleanup.md (NEW ~218 LOC)

Slug remains COMPLETED — verified, axiom-free, sorry-free per
state.md head, JSON top-level, and the source file
proofs/Proofs/EhrhartCrossPolytope.lean (720 LOC, 22 thm, 0 sorries,
0 axioms, 2 defs).

Test plan

  • python3 -c "import json; json.load(open('src/data/research/problems/ehrhart-cube-proven-oq-02.json'))"JSON OK
  • git diff --stat origin/main shows exactly 3 paths
  • No .lean files touched
  • No problem.md / knowledge.md edits (knowledge.md staleness handoff in S8 memo §3)
  • No leanFiles[0] edits (already accurate: 720/22/0/0/2 verified at S8 author time)
  • No Docker build needed (zero proof delta)
  • No conflict (no open PRs for this slug)
  • Verification commands in S8 memo §2 re-runnable on origin/main

Out-of-PR side-effects

🤖 Generated with Claude Code

…p + currentState.nextAction realignment + sessions/ bootstrap + knowledge.md handoff (doc-only)

The 2026-05-13/14 STATE-SYNC (PR #18953) was a thorough top-level
refresh (top-level JSON phase/status/progressSummary + leanFiles[0]
counts to S7 outcome; removed a duplicate stale S6 block). S8 absorbs
the residual drift it did not explicitly scope:

* knowledge.nextSteps 3 -> 4 items: drop 2 already-discharged (S7
  slicing-prototype DONE in PR #17362; S8 sorryCount=0/status=verified
  DONE per JSON top-level); keep S9 reframed as "dedicated-slug
  candidate" for central Delannoy upstream Mathlib contribution; add 3
  cosmetic follow-ups from state.md "Follow-Up (optional,
  post-completion)" list (set/refine cosmetic refactor; le_or_lt
  deprecation warning; permutohedron/hypersimplex/flow-polytope
  dedicated-slug candidates).
* currentState.nextAction rewritten to match state.md Follow-Up +
  cross-reference S8 memo §3 for knowledge.md staleness handoff.
* sessions/ subdirectory bootstrapped with new S8 memo (~218 LOC, 8
  sections). The existing session-5-slicing-spec.md is LEFT IN PLACE
  at the slug-dir root (do not git-mv; more invasive than S8 scope).
* knowledge.md line ~10 ("Two sorries remain") factual staleness
  FLAGGED in S8 memo §3 as a ready-to-paste diff for downstream
  mechanic/researcher; not edited here (knowledge.md is
  research/domain territory, not STATE-SYNC territory).

3 files, conflict-free (no open PRs for this slug; PR #17030 surfaced
by search is for cantor-diagonalization-oq-04-oq-01 via cross-ref):
* research/problems/<slug>/state.md (head + S8 entry)
* src/data/research/problems/<slug>.json (5 fields: iteration/focus/
  nextAction/nextSteps/lastUpdate)
* research/problems/<slug>/sessions/2026-05-16-s8-state-sync-nextsteps-cleanup.md (NEW ~218 LOC)

No Lean edits, no proofs/ changes, no problem.md edits, no knowledge.md
edits, no leanFiles[0] edits (verified at S8 author time:
720/22/0/0/2 matches JSON exactly).

Slug remains COMPLETED - verified, axiom-free, sorry-free per state.md
head, JSON top-level, and the source file
proofs/Proofs/EhrhartCrossPolytope.lean (720 LOC, 22 thm, 0 sorries,
0 axioms, 2 defs).

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 <noreply@anthropic.com>
@rjwalters rjwalters merged commit bccfbe6 into main May 16, 2026
@rjwalters rjwalters deleted the research/researcher-4-ehrhart-cube-oq02-s1429Z branch May 16, 2026 14:32
rjwalters added a commit that referenced this pull request May 16, 2026
…rries remain" → both closed (S2 #16734, S7 #17362) (#19672)

Applies the ready-to-paste 5-LOC diff from PR #19637 (S8 STATE-SYNC) §3
knowledge.md staleness handoff package.

Both sorries were closed:
- crossEhrhart_is_poly: closed in S2 (PR #16734, 2026-05-07) via
  descPochhammer routing. Visible sorry-free at
  proofs/Proofs/EhrhartCrossPolytope.lean:298.
- crossBall_card succ: closed in S7 (PR #17362, 2026-05-08) via the
  three-piece slicing decomposition. Visible sorry-free at
  proofs/Proofs/EhrhartCrossPolytope.lean:662.

Slug remains COMPLETED — verified, axiom-free, sorry-free per JSON
top-level + state.md head.

Handoff source: #19637 (researcher-4, merged 2026-05-16T14:32Z)

🤖 Generated with [Claude Code](https://claude.com/claude-code)

Co-authored-by: Robb Walters <r.j.walters@gmail.com>
Co-authored-by: Claude Opus 4.7 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Labels

None yet

Projects

None yet

Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

1 participant