Rework the functionality of PIP_CONFIG_FILE (#11850)

docs/html/topics/configuration.md

@@ -19,20 +19,24 @@ and how they are related to pip's various command line options.
 
 ## Configuration Files
 
-Configuration files can change the default values for command line option.
-They are written using a standard INI style configuration files.
+Configuration files can change the default values for command line options.
+The files are written using standard INI format.
 
 pip has 3 "levels" of configuration files:
 
 - `global`: system-wide configuration file, shared across users.
 - `user`: per-user configuration file.
 - `site`: per-environment configuration file; i.e. per-virtualenv.
 
+Additionally, environment variables can be specified which will override any of the above.
+
 ### Location
 
 pip's configuration files are located in fairly standard locations. This
 location is different on different operating systems, and has some additional
-complexity for backwards compatibility reasons.
+complexity for backwards compatibility reasons. Note that if user config files
+exist in both the legacy and current locations, values in the current file
+will override values in the legacy file.
 
 ```{tab} Unix
 
@@ -88,9 +92,10 @@ Site
 ### `PIP_CONFIG_FILE`
 
 Additionally, the environment variable `PIP_CONFIG_FILE` can be used to specify
-a configuration file that's loaded first, and whose values are overridden by
-the values set in the aforementioned files. Setting this to {any}`os.devnull`
-disables the loading of _all_ configuration files.
+a configuration file that's loaded last, and whose values override the values
+set in the aforementioned files. Setting this to {any}`os.devnull`
+disables the loading of _all_ configuration files. Note that if a file exists
+at the location that this is set to, the user config file will not be loaded.
 
 (config-precedence)=
 
@@ -99,10 +104,10 @@ disables the loading of _all_ configuration files.
 When multiple configuration files are found, pip combines them in the following
 order:
 
-- `PIP_CONFIG_FILE`, if given.
 - Global
 - User
 - Site
+- `PIP_CONFIG_FILE`, if given.
 
 Each file read overrides any values read from previous files, so if the
 global timeout is specified in both the global file and the per-user file

news/11815.doc.rst

@@ -0,0 +1 @@
+Fix explanation of how PIP_CONFIG_FILE works

src/pip/_internal/configuration.py

@@ -327,33 +327,35 @@ def get_environ_vars(self) -> Iterable[Tuple[str, str]]:
     def iter_config_files(self) -> Iterable[Tuple[Kind, List[str]]]:
         """Yields variant and configuration files associated with it.
 
-        This should be treated like items of a dictionary.
+        This should be treated like items of a dictionary. The order
+        here doesn't affect what gets overridden. That is controlled
+        by OVERRIDE_ORDER. However this does control the order they are
+        displayed to the user. It's probably most ergononmic to display
+        things in the same order as OVERRIDE_ORDER
         """
         # SMELL: Move the conditions out of this function
 
-        # environment variables have the lowest priority
-        config_file = os.environ.get("PIP_CONFIG_FILE", None)
-        if config_file is not None:
-            yield kinds.ENV, [config_file]
-        else:
-            yield kinds.ENV, []
-
+        env_config_file = os.environ.get("PIP_CONFIG_FILE", None)
         config_files = get_configuration_files()
 
-        # at the base we have any global configuration
         yield kinds.GLOBAL, config_files[kinds.GLOBAL]
 
-        # per-user configuration next
+        # per-user config is not loaded when env_config_file exists
         should_load_user_config = not self.isolated and not (
-            config_file and os.path.exists(config_file)
+            env_config_file and os.path.exists(env_config_file)
         )
         if should_load_user_config:
             # The legacy config file is overridden by the new config file
             yield kinds.USER, config_files[kinds.USER]
 
-        # finally virtualenv configuration first trumping others
+        # virtualenv config
         yield kinds.SITE, config_files[kinds.SITE]
 
+        if env_config_file is not None:
+            yield kinds.ENV, [env_config_file]
+        else:
+            yield kinds.ENV, []
+
     def get_values_in_config(self, variant: Kind) -> Dict[str, Any]:
         """Get values present in a config file"""
         return self._config[variant]