Skip to content

Hosted overlay is missing FountainBrokerCAInstallFailureRate (and three other portable rules) #2041

Description

@jhgaylor

What is missing

FountainBrokerCAInstallFailureRate shipped in the portable rules (#1958), but
the hosted instance does not read that file. deploy/k8s/kustomization.yaml
keeps prometheusrule.yaml commented out, and
jhgaylor/home-cloud at platform/fountain-site/prometheusrule.yaml is a
hand-maintained copy of the rules rather than a reference to the portable
one. Until that copy gains the rule, the alert exists in the repository and
fires nowhere.

This matters more than usual here: the alert is ask 3 of #1671, and ask 1
(why CA installs regressed 0 -> 18% on 2026-09-06) is the one that needs the
signal in production to make progress.

The drift is not new

Diffing the two files today, three portable rules were already never copied
across:

  • FountainReattachFailures
  • FountainTurnFailureRate
  • FountainTurnFirstOutputSlow

FountainBrokerCAInstallFailureRate becomes the fourth. The observability
guide already warns that "the hosted overlay requires its own rollout; a merge
of this file does not update it", so nothing is behaving unexpectedly; there is
just no gate that notices when the two drift apart.

Asks

  1. Add FountainBrokerCAInstallFailureRate to
    platform/fountain-site/prometheusrule.yaml in jhgaylor/home-cloud and
    roll it out. Do this after the metric is actually being scraped in
    production, so the rule is not evaluating an absent series.
  2. Decide whether the other three belong in the overlay, or whether they were
    deliberately left out.
  3. Consider a check that diffs portable alert names against the overlay's, in
    whichever repo can see both. The docs table already has a name-parity test
    (Fountain.DocsTest, "the portable alert table matches the shipped rule
    names") and this is the same shape one level out.

Verifying

The metric only exists once the image carrying #1957 is running. Confirm the
series is present before adding the rule:

fountain_broker_ca_install_count{namespace="fountain"}

Activity

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

No one assigned

    Labels

    P2Worth doing, not urgentarea:opsObservability, resilience, deploys, databugSomething isn't working

    Type

    No type

    Projects

    No projects

      Milestone

      No milestone

      Relationships

      None yet

      Development

      No branches or pull requests

      Issue actions