chore: preserve historical September 11 Beads audit events - #449
Conversation
Retain 18 existing generated journal events byte-for-byte as historical records, not current acceptance or replayed source transitions. No database, mirror, protocol, or support status changes. Co-authored-by: Copilot <223556219+Copilot@users.noreply.github.com>
|
The latest updates on your projects. Learn more about Vercel for GitHub.
|
There was a problem hiding this comment.
🔵 Needs a closer look
Hosted exact-head checks and the parent independent R4 review remain pending.
Pull request overview
Preserves 18 historical September 11 Beads audit events in .beads/interactions.jsonl without changing current authority or source state.
Changes:
- Appends the original 18 JSONL audit records chronologically.
- Retains IDs, timestamps, wording, repeated statuses, and historical claims.
- Includes artifact integrity and validation evidence.
File summaries
| File | Description |
|---|---|
.beads/interactions.jsonl |
Adds 18 preserved historical audit events. |
Review details
- Files reviewed: 1/1 changed files
- Comments generated: 0
- Review effort level: Lite
💡 Configure MCP servers for context-aware, tailored reviews. Learn more in the docs.
|
Independent R4 review completed on exact head |
Scope and authority
Preserve 18 already-generated September 11 audit events in
.beads/interactions.jsonl, with explicit owner authorization to preserve the dirty journal in Git. Historical preservation only; DO NOT MERGE in this task. Parent independent R4 review, terminal exact-head required checks, normal protected merge, and subsequent root reconciliation remain pending.These are chronological events, not current authority or new acceptance evidence. Repeated statuses, distinct event IDs, old completion claims, candidate-head claims, and their original wording remain intact. No deduplication by issue/status, correction, transition replay, or present-day closure is performed. No protocol, support, source, or mirror status changes are asserted.
The root journal was backed up privately before integration and remains unchanged and unstaged. Only the 18 appended records were integrated with
apply_patchinto a clean worktree branched from fetchedorigin/main; no wholesale overwrite of newer upstream was performed. No other worktree was modified or removed. No Beads CLI/database access, export, migration, Dolt operation, or synchronizer application occurred.Exact artifact and preservation evidence
Base:
ec28705ca2ac693bdfbd3ee959a0c9c6def23b07(PR #448 merged). Commit:d42a3d3cb9a9d00f2c6c6b589efdf24a8ea1c0af.Exact diff:
.beads/interactions.jsonlonly, 18 additions / 0 deletions, lines 97-114. Base contains 96, not 97, records. Root HEAD and fetched upstream journal were byte-identical; there were no overlapping appended IDs to reconcile.c7951d345033684318934238e478165a1bfe8a6d22220382ecc0e9a405516a6f2ff0cf1f61630aa45482d0870302a80dacdfb10885d75c799d10872079e16a2107215c3a9b32a96da7cfb8aa26cc02c24c9927ade7306ee9a28c70768504ba9ePatch SHA-256:
e5c314bc3585234508685fc93d57865dbfbdfde144cf8294af7a53bee3e0ae0e, reproducible with:Byte comparisons against the private backup passed before commit. JSON parsing, all 114 unique IDs, expected appended event shape, September 11 timestamp ordering, exact 34004-byte prefix, exact 10712-byte suffix, and final newline passed. Manual review of every added field plus bounded sensitive-pattern screening found no credentials, raw private paths, raw prompts, or private endpoints. Public historical actor attribution is unchanged. No raw database export or unrestricted logs are retained or published.
Bounded provenance
Read-only
gh pr view NUMBER --json number,state,headRefOid,mergeCommit,mergedAtconfirmed merged PR identities for #429, #436, #438, #439, #440, #441, #442, and #443. Their recorded merge references agree with GitHub metadata. This establishes reference identity only, not historical suite counts, review verdicts, current source state, or acceptance.In particular, the earlier #440 candidate SHA is retained as an old candidate claim, not represented as the final merged head. The later event identifies head
a9c0e2c8a75063198eba86120051f6a08617e0e4and merge3660351077eb4e9d5c68001ee9907a1ef1c21499. Repeated completion narratives are intentionally not reconciled. Physical-device, simulator, GPU, and lost-reply proof gaps are not adjudicated by this PR.Validation
Executed on the exact tree committed as
d42a3d3cb9a9d00f2c6c6b589efdf24a8ea1c0af:Results: focused governance/synchronizer tests 403 passed; isolated renderer tests 221 passed; full source gate passed, including tests, documentation, typecheck, smoke, packaging, deterministic bundles, Rust formatting/tests/check. No tracked/untracked drift from the gate. iOS opt-in simulator gate was not enabled; no new iOS/device/distribution acceptance is claimed. Existing Rust warnings were non-fatal. Hosted exact-head checks and parent independent R4 review are still separate merge gates.
Rollback and handoff
Before merge, leave the PR unmerged; the original root journal and private backup preserve all events. Any post-merge rollback must be a separately reviewed Git revert, not a database reversal or mirror mutation. The parent must compare the live root with the original digest and check for concurrent appended events before any cleanup; this task deliberately leaves the root dirty. No branch/worktree removal or root cleanup is authorized by this PR.