Skip to content

Promote clone and receive-pack parity to implemented#27

Merged
Ismail-elkorchi merged 1 commit into
mainfrom
clone-receive-pack-parity-gate-hardening
Feb 17, 2026
Merged

Promote clone and receive-pack parity to implemented#27
Ismail-elkorchi merged 1 commit into
mainfrom
clone-receive-pack-parity-gate-hardening

Conversation

@Ismail-elkorchi

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Owner

Acceptance Criteria

  • clone and receive-pack plumbing parity family MUST be machine-checkable when marked implemented.
  • parity roadmap and matrix MUST set clone-receive-pack-plumbing to implemented with matching states.
  • an invariant MUST map clone/receive-pack parity requirements to enforceable evidence gates.

Checklist

  • Added INV-FEAT-0053 to spec/invariants.yaml with evidence mapping.
  • Added INV-FEAT-0053 gate handler in scripts/check.
  • Added implemented-state evidence enforcement for clone/receive-pack in scripts/parity_matrix_check.
  • Promoted clone/receive-pack state to implemented in spec/parity-roadmap.yaml and docs/parity-matrix.md.
  • Ran node scripts/check --runtime=node.

Simulated Role Reviews

Product review

Findings:

  • The only remaining partial command family is now promoted with explicit enforcement instead of text-only claims.
  • Implemented state now reflects a concrete proof path for clone branch parity and receive-pack behavior.
    Changes made:
  • Updated roadmap and parity matrix states for clone/receive-pack to implemented.
  • Added invariant coverage entry INV-FEAT-0053.
    Evidence pointers:
  • spec/parity-roadmap.yaml
  • docs/parity-matrix.md
  • spec/invariants.yaml

QA review

Findings:

  • Implemented-state validation now fails if clone/receive-pack APIs or baseline-backed tests are missing.
  • Existing node tests already provide the necessary counterexample surface for regression detection.
    Changes made:
  • Added clone/receive-pack checks in scripts/parity_matrix_check.
  • Added INV-FEAT-0053 handler requirements in scripts/check.
    Evidence pointers:
  • scripts/parity_matrix_check
  • scripts/check
  • tests/node/clone-receive-pack.test.mjs

Security review

Findings:

  • Gate hardening reduces governance drift risk where implemented labels could outpace verifiable behavior.
  • Evidence generation now includes clone/receive-pack invariant artifacts under the active phase.
    Changes made:
  • Added new invariant with explicit falsification method and implementation surface mapping.
  • Bound invariant enforcement to existing CI check path.
    Evidence pointers:
  • spec/invariants.yaml
  • scripts/check

Performance review

Findings:

  • Changes are policy/gate logic only with no runtime-path overhead in shipped library execution.
  • Additional checks run in CI script validation and are bounded to file/text assertions.
    Changes made:
  • Extended parity checker with targeted string and regex assertions.
  • Kept checks scoped to one test file and API signatures.
    Evidence pointers:
  • scripts/parity_matrix_check
  • node scripts/check --runtime=node

Maintainer review

Findings:

  • Roadmap/matrix/state coherence is now enforced for clone/receive-pack in the same pattern as repo/backfill/replay/last-modified.
  • Invariant catalog now covers the newly implemented family with explicit ID tracking.
    Changes made:
  • Added required family id assertion for clone-receive-pack.
  • Added invariant definition and gate handler for INV-FEAT-0053.
    Evidence pointers:
  • scripts/parity_matrix_check
  • spec/invariants.yaml
  • scripts/check

@Ismail-elkorchi Ismail-elkorchi merged commit e394416 into main Feb 17, 2026
7 checks passed
@Ismail-elkorchi Ismail-elkorchi deleted the clone-receive-pack-parity-gate-hardening branch February 17, 2026 00:28
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Labels

None yet

Projects

None yet

Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

1 participant