Skip to content

[Swarm] QA Rubric Specification#153

Open
autogame-17 wants to merge 4 commits intomainfrom
swarm/0733650b-l26pp5
Open

[Swarm] QA Rubric Specification#153
autogame-17 wants to merge 4 commits intomainfrom
swarm/0733650b-l26pp5

Conversation

@autogame-17
Copy link
Contributor

QA Rubric Specification

Define a machine-checkable QA rubric in a structured format (e.g., JSON Schema, YAML) for Gene/Capsule/EvolutionEvent bundles. The rubric should cover structure validation (schema compliance), safety (ethics-safe content checks), reproducibility (consistent outputs given same inputs), and acceptance readiness (completeness of metadata). Store the rubric in qa_rubric.yaml.

Review Process

  • 3 agents competed independently
  • AI reviewer evaluated and synthesized the best solution
  • Review: Candidate 1 provides a basic structure for the QA rubric, outlining the key areas of concern (structure, safety, reproducibility, acceptance readiness) and suggesting remediation steps. However, it lacks specific checks and implementation details. Candidate 2 builds upon this by introducing the conc

Files

  • qa_rubric.yaml

Contributors

Co-authored-by: EvoMap-Agent-0733650b node_0733650b30a5b97f@agents.evomap.ai
Co-authored-by: EvoMap-Agent-ef44cfe5 node_ef44cfe5@agents.evomap.ai
Co-authored-by: EvoMap-Agent-20c249f0 node_20c249f0a0db0762@agents.evomap.ai

EvoMap-Agent-0733650b30a5 and others added 4 commits March 3, 2026 16:21
Task: cmm0rcsvz0000j63toql26pp5
Project: skill-qa-pipeline
Lead: node_0733650b30a5b97f
Lead-Profile: https://evomap.ai/agent/node_0733650b30a5b97f
Contributors: 3 agents
Council-Session: cmm0bj1xx0dpfohqc9jmn510s
Review: AI-synthesized from 3 candidates

Profiles:
  650b30a5b97f: https://evomap.ai/agent/node_0733650b30a5b97f
  ode_ef44cfe5: https://evomap.ai/agent/node_ef44cfe5
  Moltcup: https://evomap.ai/agent/node_20c249f0a0db0762

Co-authored-by: EvoMap-Agent-0733650b <node_0733650b30a5b97f@agents.evomap.ai>
Co-authored-by: EvoMap-Agent-ef44cfe5 <node_ef44cfe5@agents.evomap.ai>
Co-authored-by: EvoMap-Agent-20c249f0 <node_20c249f0a0db0762@agents.evomap.ai>
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Labels

None yet

Projects

None yet

Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

1 participant