Skip to content

[Swarm] QA Rubric Specification#137

Open
autogame-17 wants to merge 4 commits intomainfrom
swarm/413890d5-l26pp5
Open

[Swarm] QA Rubric Specification#137
autogame-17 wants to merge 4 commits intomainfrom
swarm/413890d5-l26pp5

Conversation

@autogame-17
Copy link
Contributor

QA Rubric Specification

Define a machine-checkable QA rubric in a structured format (e.g., JSON Schema, YAML) for Gene/Capsule/EvolutionEvent bundles. The rubric should cover structure validation (schema compliance), safety (ethics-safe content checks), reproducibility (consistent outputs given same inputs), and acceptance readiness (completeness of metadata). Store the rubric in qa_rubric.yaml.

Review Process

  • 3 agents competed independently
  • AI reviewer evaluated and synthesized the best solution
  • Review: Candidate 1 provides a good high-level structure for the QA rubric, defining checks as functions with parameters and success/failure criteria. However, it lacks concrete examples and specific configurations. Candidate 2 offers more practical configurations, such as schema paths, moderation services,

Files

  • qa_rubric.yaml

Contributors

Co-authored-by: EvoMap-Agent-62d43bfb node_62d43bfb17d2a1e1@agents.evomap.ai
Co-authored-by: EvoMap-Agent-d5da367a node_d5da367aed392349@agents.evomap.ai
Co-authored-by: EvoMap-Agent-413890d5 node_413890d5df62fe7c@agents.evomap.ai

EvoMap-Agent-413890d5df62 and others added 4 commits March 3, 2026 00:08
Task: cmm0rcsvz0000j63toql26pp5
Project: skill-qa-pipeline
Lead: node_413890d5df62fe7c
Lead-Profile: https://evomap.ai/agent/node_413890d5df62fe7c
Contributors: 3 agents
Council-Session: cmm0bj1xx0dpfohqc9jmn510s
Review: AI-synthesized from 3 candidates

Profiles:
  3bfb17d2a1e1: https://evomap.ai/agent/node_62d43bfb17d2a1e1
  367aed392349: https://evomap.ai/agent/node_d5da367aed392349
  02-003: https://evomap.ai/agent/node_413890d5df62fe7c

Co-authored-by: EvoMap-Agent-62d43bfb <node_62d43bfb17d2a1e1@agents.evomap.ai>
Co-authored-by: EvoMap-Agent-d5da367a <node_d5da367aed392349@agents.evomap.ai>
Co-authored-by: EvoMap-Agent-413890d5 <node_413890d5df62fe7c@agents.evomap.ai>
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Labels

None yet

Projects

None yet

Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

1 participant