[PR Triage Report] Agent PR Triage Report — 2026-03-09 — 3 PRs (ALL EXTREME RISK)

[github-actions]

Triage Summary

Timestamp: 2026-03-09T02:32:47Z
Workflow Run: 22835930392
Total Agent PRs: 3 (all Claude Code generated)

Overall Health: 🔴 CRITICAL

• 0 PRs ready to merge
• 3/3 (100%) EXTREME risk level
• 2/3 (66%) have merge conflicts
• 3/3 (100%) are oversized (>40 files each)
• 0 CI checks configured (cannot verify tests pass)

---

PR Analysis

🆕 PR #2962: Remove Python Recipe Runner (BLOCKING)

Category: Breaking Change
Risk: 🔴 EXTREME
Priority: 🔴 CRITICAL
Mergeable: ✅ Yes
Status: BLOCKED — Do Not Merge

Stats: 41 files, +401/-12,278, 3 commits

Blockers:

• ❌ Breaking change — Removes entire Python recipe runner (12K LOC)
• ❌ Hard dependency on external Rust binary recipe-runner-rs
• ❌ Test plan incomplete — unchecked: "CI passes", "Verify recipe-runner-rs in CI"
• ❌ No fallback strategy for environments without Rust toolchain
• ❌ Removes 10,818 LOC of test coverage (24 test files deleted)

Recommendation: BLOCK until prerequisites met

1. Install recipe-runner-rs in CI environment
2. Verify all tests pass with Rust runner
3. Document fallback strategy (or accept breakage for non-Rust envs)
4. Add CI check that fails if Rust binary missing

Migration Impact: Every user must install Rust toolchain + cargo binary. This is a major breaking change that needs communication plan.

---

📦 PR #2876: Distributed Hive Mind (DECOMPOSE)

Category: Feature
Risk: 🔴 EXTREME
Priority: 🟠 HIGH
Mergeable: ❌ No (conflicts)
Status: ONGOING (5 days old)

Stats: 157 files, +24,351/-6,210, 74 commits

Blockers:

• ❌ Extreme complexity — 157 files, 24K additions
• ❌ Merge conflicts (unknown mergeable state)
• ❌ Bundled features — HiveMind + DHT + Eval improvements
• ⚠️ Unreviewable scope — impossible to verify correctness

Recommendation: DECOMPOSE into 3-4 focused PRs

Split into:

1. PR 1: HiveMindOrchestrator core (storage + transport layers)
2. PR 2: DHT sharding implementation
3. PR 3: Eval improvements with benchmarks (51.2% → 83.9% claim)
4. PR 4: Documentation and integration

Current size creates unacceptable merge risk and makes rollback impossible.

---

🗑️ PR #2727: Fleet Orchestration (CLOSE)

Category: Feature
Risk: 🔴 EXTREME
Priority: ⚪ LOW
Mergeable: ❌ No (conflicts)
Status: STALE (9 days old)

Stats: 132 files, +31,402/-605, 167 commits

Blockers:

• ❌ Extremely stale — 9 days, 167 commits
• ❌ Massive scope — 132 files, 31K additions
• ❌ Severe merge conflicts (likely unmergeable)
• ❌ Bundled changes — module splits, backend fixes, tests, discovery

Recommendation: CLOSE and restart with incremental PRs

This PR is beyond salvage. After 9 days and 167 commits:

1. Close this PR immediately
2. Extract critical bug fixes into hotfix PR (<5 files each)
3. Create incremental feature PRs with proper sequencing:
   • PR 1: Core fleet session lifecycle (foundation)
   • PR 2: Backend integration
   • PR 3: Test coverage
   • PR 4: Azlin discovery

---

Critical System Issues

1. 100% of PRs are Oversized

Impact: All PRs are unreviewable
Recommendation: Implement hard limits:

• Max 20 files per PR
• Max 2,000 LOC changed per PR
• Agent workflow should auto-split large changes

2. No CI Checks Configured

Impact: Cannot verify tests pass, builds succeed, or lints pass
Recommendation: Configure GitHub Actions to run on every PR:

• Run test suite
• Run linters (ruff, mypy)
• Verify build succeeds

3. 66% Have Merge Conflicts

Impact: Blocks automated merging, indicates branch divergence
Recommendation: Implement SLA:

• Review within 24 hours
• Merge/close decision within 72 hours
• Daily auto-rebase for agent PRs

4. PR #2962 Breaking Change Risk

Impact: All recipe execution breaks without Rust binary
Recommendation: Before merge:

• Add Rust binary to CI
• Document migration path
• Create fallback or accept breakage

5. Average PR Age: 5 Days

Impact: Stale PRs accumulate conflicts and become unmergeable
Recommendation: Implement merge urgency:

• New PRs: merge within 48h or close
• 3+ day PRs: rebase or close
• 7+ day PRs: auto-close

---

Next Actions (Priority Order)

1️⃣ BLOCK PR #2962 (Immediate)

• Add "do-not-merge" label
• Comment on PR explaining blockers
• Create issue for "Add recipe-runner-rs to CI"
• Estimated effort: 2-4 hours to fix CI

2️⃣ CLOSE PR #2727 (Today)

• Close PR with explanation
• Extract critical bug fixes (if any) into hotfix PR
• Create roadmap for incremental fleet PRs
• Estimated effort: 30 minutes to close, 4-6 hours to decompose

3️⃣ DECOMPOSE PR #2876 (This Week)

• Request author to split into 3-4 PRs
• Provide decomposition guide
• Close original PR once splits created
• Estimated effort: 6-8 hours to decompose properly

4️⃣ Configure CI Checks (This Week)

• Add GitHub Actions workflow for PR checks
• Run tests, linters, build on every PR
• Estimated effort: 1-2 hours

---

Comparison to Previous Triage

Previous triage (2026-03-08-18Z): 4 PRs analyzed

• Closed/merged since: feat: Rust recipe runner integration with engine selection #2951 (conflicts), feat: integrate /top5 priority aggregation into pm-architect #2941 (ready to merge)
• Still open: feat: distributed hive mind with DHT sharding + improved eval recall (51.2% → ≥83.9%) #2876, feat: Fleet Orchestration — autonomous multi-VM coding agent management #2727
• New: feat!: remove Python recipe runner — Rust-only execution #2962

Progress: 2 PRs resolved, but new breaking change PR is highest risk yet.

---

References

• Detailed triage: /tmp/gh-aw/repo-memory/default/pr-triage-2026-03-09-02Z.json
• Previous triage: /tmp/gh-aw/repo-memory/default/pr-triage-2026-03-08-18Z.json
• Workflow run: https://github.com/rysweet/amplihack/actions/runs/22835930392

Generated by PR Triage Agent

• expires on Mar 10, 2026, 2:40 AM UTC