[Enhancement]: My Collection Concept

[brent-hartwig]

Priority Level

Medium

Background

The backend's implementation of the upcoming MyCollections feature will need the ability to differentiate a My Collection Set from other Sets. For example, the backend should not accept a create or update request for non-My Collection Sets.

Description

Please add a record for the concept of a My Collection, and provide it an equivalent ID that will not change between LUX dataset versions.

Set as medium given the MVP's timeline and ability to use a temporary ID for development and testing.

Changes Required

See above

Example

Tasks

• Task 1
• Task 2
• Task 3

Related Issues

Blocking: project-lux/lux-marklogic#504

project-lux/lux-marklogic#486

[brent-hartwig]

@azaroth42 and @kkdavis14, we have implemented additional temporary concept IRIs. Could you add these to the dataset or identify existing ones we can use? I defer to you as to whether the first two are specific to My Collections or even Sets.

1. A note in a My Collection.
2. A label for the note.
3. A user profile.
4. A user ID.

We are using http://www.wikidata.org/entity/Q15901043 for a user's name.

Thank you.

@jffcamp and @prowns, timing:

1. Need before we start creating production data.
2. If not before end-to-end testing, the frontend and backend would need to use the same temporary values.

cc: @clarkepeterf, @kamerynB

[kkdavis14]

@brent-hartwig taking my best shot here. there was a convo in Teams that I am using for reference:
https://teams.microsoft.com/l/message/19:351e0281aaa144d0812b960d216958c6@thread.tacv2/1744828648490?tenantId=dd8cbebb-2139-4df8-b411-4e3e87abeb5c&groupId=4620eac6-0955-4c69-93e8-b493b21f0df6&parentMessageId=1744828648490&teamName=ML%2F%20Cultural%20Heritage%20Support&channelName=1%20-%20LUX_ML&createdTime=1744828648490

we will want to use AAT whenever possible. We have LUX UUIDs for some things here, but they aren't 100% stable, and won't exist if the AAT hasn't been referenced yet. for example the "alias" id below isn't in LUX right now.

A note in a My Collection: current LUX https://lux.collections.yale.edu/data/concept/b9d84f17-662e-46ef-ab8b-7499717f8337
AAT: http://vocab.getty.edu/aat/300435416
A label for the note: according to project-lux/lux-frontend#639, this is user entered content.

the rest I am either reaching for appropriate AATs or there isn't one. We may consider asking them to add IDs for us to use (they've been very accommodating about this in the past).
A user profile: http://www.wikidata.org/entity/Q252500 "user profile"
A user ID: what's the difference between this and user name?
A user name: http://vocab.getty.edu/aat/300404664 "alias"

[brent-hartwig]

Thanks, @kkdavis14. Here's how I'm marking up user ID, user profile, and username:

cc: @clarkepeterf

[kkdavis14]

thanks @brent-hartwig that helps visualize this.

the user ID would just be the UUID, no?
do my suggested AATs/Wikidatas work for you? My guess is if we can swap out your WQID for user name to the AAT for alias, we'd like to. but there's no good AAT for "user profile", unless we ask them to add.

[brent-hartwig]

Thanks, @kkdavis14. I think this is where we stand on the requested concepts:

1. My Collection: not yet identified. Original scope of this ticket.
2. Collection note: start using http://vocab.getty.edu/aat/300435416
3. Collection label: not yet identified. Agreed the associated content property value is specified by the user, but unless a note can only be identified by a label, I need a UUID for label. See example below.
4. User profile: start using http://www.wikidata.org/entity/Q252500
5. User ID: correct, the user ID is one in the same as their UUID (and URI in MarkLogic).
6. Username: switch from http://www.wikidata.org/entity/Q15901043 to http://vocab.getty.edu/aat/300404664. I think alias given we presently go from username to user ID; if it was the other way around, alias may be too generic.

Annotated My Collection:

[kkdavis14]

@brent-hartwig

we do not have a "my collections" ID to use for the classification there on the Set...I am not sure what will be best there. There's certainly no AAT that is close enough. Wikidata is really vague, there's user-generated content but obviously we're not going to find "My Collections" as a classifier anywhere.

as for number 3, "Collection label: not yet identified. Agreed the associated content property value is specified by the user, but unless a note can only be identified by a label, I need a UUID for label. See example below."

@kamerynB can you chime in? we may need to discuss this live as I think we're confusing each other. is this a dropdown of possible classifications for the content written by the user?

[kamerynB]

@kkdavis14 @brent-hartwig

I hope this helps.

1. My Collection: not yet identified. Original scope of this ticket.
   My thoughts: Rob has suggested the classification of a user's collection will be Personal Collection. What that AAT is? I don't know.
2. Collection note: start using http://vocab.getty.edu/aat/300435416
   My thoughts: Yes, this will be the default classified_as AAT used for a given note, which is in the collection's referred_to_by.
3. Collection label: not yet identified. Agreed the associated content property value is specified by the user, but unless a note can only be identified by a label, I need a UUID for label. See example below.
   My thoughts: The label is entered by the user and will (most likely) be stored within the referred_to_by/[index of note]/identified_by/content. The classified_as/AAT of this label is not important to the frontend. It will just look for identified_by on each note. Whatever is decided on how to classify that is fine by me.
4. User profile: start using http://www.wikidata.org/entity/Q252500
   My thoughts: I have none on this matter.
5. User ID: correct, the user ID is one in the same as their UUID (and URI in MarkLogic).
   My thoughts: ????
6. Username: switch from http://www.wikidata.org/entity/Q15901043 to http://vocab.getty.edu/aat/300404664. I think alias given we presently go from username to user ID; if it was the other way around, alias may be too generic.
   My thoughts: Sure??

[kkdavis14]

not finding an AAT or Wikidata for Personal Collection to tbd on an URI for that.