Summary
The gh please pr review reply command fails with a GraphQL schema error because the pullRequestReviewThread field doesn't exist on the PullRequestReviewComment type.
Error Message
❌ Error: GraphQL query failed: gh: Field 'pullRequestReviewThread' doesn't exist on type 'PullRequestReviewComment'
Root Cause
In src/lib/github/review-operations.ts, the getThreadIdFromComment function (lines 89-115) uses an invalid GraphQL query:
query GetThreadFromComment($commentId: ID!) {
node(id: $commentId) {
... on PullRequestReviewComment {
pullRequestReviewThread { # ← This field doesn't exist!
id
}
}
}
}The GitHub GraphQL schema does not have a pullRequestReviewThread field on the PullRequestReviewComment type.
Steps to Reproduce
gh please pr review reply PRRC_kwDOxxxxxx -b "test reply"
Expected Behavior
The command should successfully create a reply to the review comment.
Actual Behavior
The command fails with the GraphQL schema error.
Suggested Fix
Option 1: Use PR's reviewThreads and match by comment ID
query GetThreadFromComment($prId: ID!, $commentId: ID!) {
node(id: $prId) {
... on PullRequest {
reviewThreads(first: 100) {
nodes {
id
comments(first: 100) {
nodes {
id
}
}
}
}
}
}
}Then find the thread that contains the target comment ID.
Option 2: Use REST API fallback
# Get all review comments and find thread relationship via in_reply_to_id
GET /repos/{owner}/{repo}/pulls/{pull_number}/commentsEnvironment
- gh-please version: latest
- gh version: 2.x
- OS: Linux/macOS
Summary
The
gh please pr review replycommand fails with a GraphQL schema error because thepullRequestReviewThreadfield doesn't exist on thePullRequestReviewCommenttype.Error Message
Root Cause
In
src/lib/github/review-operations.ts, thegetThreadIdFromCommentfunction (lines 89-115) uses an invalid GraphQL query:The GitHub GraphQL schema does not have a
pullRequestReviewThreadfield on thePullRequestReviewCommenttype.Steps to Reproduce
gh please pr review reply PRRC_kwDOxxxxxx -b "test reply"Expected Behavior
The command should successfully create a reply to the review comment.
Actual Behavior
The command fails with the GraphQL schema error.
Suggested Fix
Option 1: Use PR's reviewThreads and match by comment ID
Then find the thread that contains the target comment ID.
Option 2: Use REST API fallback
# Get all review comments and find thread relationship via in_reply_to_id GET /repos/{owner}/{repo}/pulls/{pull_number}/commentsEnvironment