diff --git a/baker/algolia/configureAlgolia.ts b/baker/algolia/configureAlgolia.ts
index c2fd82757bf..abb42eab36a 100644
--- a/baker/algolia/configureAlgolia.ts
+++ b/baker/algolia/configureAlgolia.ts
@@ -175,10 +175,10 @@ export const configureAlgolia = async () => {
         ],
         ranking: ["typo", "words", "exact", "attribute", "custom", "proximity"],
         customRanking: [
+            "desc(score)",
             // For multiple explorer views with the same title, we want to avoid surfacing duplicates.
             // So, rank a result with viewTitleIndexWithinExplorer=0 way more highly than one with 1, 2, etc.
             "asc(viewTitleIndexWithinExplorer)",
-            "desc(score)",
             "asc(titleLength)",
         ],
         attributesToSnippet: ["subtitle:24"],
diff --git a/baker/algolia/indexExplorerViewsAndChartsToAlgolia.ts b/baker/algolia/indexExplorerViewsAndChartsToAlgolia.ts
index 8d49784442a..1614d199d29 100644
--- a/baker/algolia/indexExplorerViewsAndChartsToAlgolia.ts
+++ b/baker/algolia/indexExplorerViewsAndChartsToAlgolia.ts
@@ -48,10 +48,14 @@ const indexExplorerViewsAndChartsToAlgolia = async () => {
                 }
             }, db.TransactionCloseMode.Close)
 
-        // Scale grapher scores between 0 and 10000, and explorer scores between 0 and 500
-        // (Except for the first view of each explorer, which we set to 10000)
-        // This is because Graphers are generally higher quality than Explorers
-        const scaledGrapherViews = scaleRecordScores(grapherViews)
+        // Scale grapher records and the default explorer views between 1000 and 10000,
+        // Scale the remaining explorer views between 0 and 1000.
+        // This is because Graphers are generally higher quality than Explorers and we don't want
+        // the data catalog to smother Grapher results with hundreds of low-quality Explorer results.
+        const scaledGrapherViews = scaleRecordScores(
+            grapherViews,
+            [1000, 10000]
+        )
         const scaledExplorerViews = adaptExplorerViews(explorerViews)
 
         const records = [...scaledGrapherViews, ...scaledExplorerViews]
diff --git a/baker/algolia/utils/explorerViews.ts b/baker/algolia/utils/explorerViews.ts
index 2d1f74ff8b8..84c2037fd4f 100644
--- a/baker/algolia/utils/explorerViews.ts
+++ b/baker/algolia/utils/explorerViews.ts
@@ -79,7 +79,7 @@ export function explorerViewRecordToChartRecord(
 /**
  * Scale explorer record scores then convert them to ChartRecords.
  * Each explorer has a default view (whichever is defined first in the decision matrix)
- * We scale these default view scores between 0 and MAX_SCORE, but the rest we scale between 0 and 500
+ * We scale these default view scores between 0 and 10000, but the rest we scale between 0 and 1000
  * to bury them under the (higher quality) grapher views in the data catalog.
  */
 export function adaptExplorerViews(
@@ -90,8 +90,8 @@ export function adaptExplorerViews(
         (view) => view.isFirstExplorerView
     )
     return [
-        ...scaleRecordScores(firstViews),
-        ...scaleRecordScores(rest, 500),
+        ...scaleRecordScores(firstViews, [1000, 10000]),
+        ...scaleRecordScores(rest, [0, 1000]),
     ].map(explorerViewRecordToChartRecord)
 }
 
diff --git a/baker/algolia/utils/shared.ts b/baker/algolia/utils/shared.ts
index 4b1f92a6669..0ebc1aef230 100644
--- a/baker/algolia/utils/shared.ts
+++ b/baker/algolia/utils/shared.ts
@@ -38,16 +38,15 @@ export const processAvailableEntities = (
     )
 }
 
-export const MAX_SCORE = 10000
-
 /**
- * Scale records' positive scores to be between 0 and MAX_SCORE.
+ * Scale records' positive scores to be between two numbers.
  */
 export function scaleRecordScores<T extends { score: number }>(
     records: T[],
-    max = MAX_SCORE
+    range: [number, number]
 ): T[] {
     const scores = records.map((r) => r.score)
+    const [min, max] = range
     const maxScore = Math.max(...scores)
     return records.map((record): T => {
         // For ExplorerView records, we want to keep negative scores,
@@ -55,7 +54,7 @@ export function scaleRecordScores<T extends { score: number }>(
         if (record.score < 0) return record
         // A value between 0 and 1
         const normalized = record.score / maxScore
-        const scaled = Math.round(normalized * max)
+        const scaled = Math.round(normalized * (max - min) + min)
         return {
             ...record,
             score: scaled,