Skip to content

incorrect accepting states #14

@hklarner

Description

@hklarner

it seems that the initial states are computed incorrectly as being all states, when the CTL spec is true everywhere. minimal example:

primes = PyBoolNet.Repository.get_primes("raf")
update = "asynchronous"
init = "INIT !Raf"
spec = "CTLSPEC TRUE"
res, acc = PyBoolNet.ModelChecking.check_primes_with_acceptingstates(primes, update, init, spec)
print acc["INIT"], acc["INIT_SIZE"]

gives TRUE, 8 but !(Raf), 4 would be correct.

NuSMV is probably lazy (i.e. efficient) and trivial specs are caught without constructing BDDs.
suggested fix for next version: ModelChecking.check_primes_with_acceptingstates(..) will test whether the ctl spec is trivial (either TRUE or FALSE) and in that case set the keywords INIT and INIT_SIZE from the accepting states dictionary to None.

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

No one assigned

    Labels

    Projects

    No projects

    Milestone

    No milestone

    Relationships

    None yet

    Development

    No branches or pull requests

    Issue actions