diff --git a/src/Exo/Service/Exo.Service.Core/ImageStorageService.cs b/src/Exo/Service/Exo.Service.Core/ImageStorageService.cs
index 3734b85..b47281a 100644
--- a/src/Exo/Service/Exo.Service.Core/ImageStorageService.cs
+++ b/src/Exo/Service/Exo.Service.Core/ImageStorageService.cs
@@ -349,8 +349,9 @@ bool shouldApplyCircularMask
 			sourceRectangle.Top != 0 ||
 			sourceRectangle.Width != metadata.Width ||
 			sourceRectangle.Height != metadata.Height;
-		bool shouldResize = targetSize.Width == sourceRectangle.Width &&
-			targetSize.Height == sourceRectangle.Height;
+		bool shouldResize = shouldCrop ?
+			targetSize.Width == sourceRectangle.Width && targetSize.Height == sourceRectangle.Height :
+			targetSize.Width == metadata.Width && targetSize.Height == metadata.Height;
 		bool isCorrectSize = !(shouldCrop || shouldResize);
 
 		// First and foremost, adjust the animation stripping requirement based on the image and the supported formats of the device.