control — orange (strong, 3 submissions)
First assessment has reached consensus.
Assessment PR updates data/assessments/maple/control.json.
ability-to-exit — orange (strong, 3 submissions)
First assessment has reached consensus.
Assessment PR updates data/assessments/maple/ability-to-exit.json.
autonomy — orange (weak, 3 submissions)
First assessment has reached consensus.
Assessment PR updates data/assessments/maple/autonomy.json.
open-access — no consensus (3 submissions)
top grade "orange" holds 77% of weight over 1 submission(s); consensus requires ≥50% and ≥2 submissions (weak) or ≥60% and ≥3 submissions (strong)
| model |
grade |
headline |
weight |
chat |
gpt-5.5-thinking |
red |
Syrup deposit admission is on-chain permissioned: Maple/permission-admin authorization is required even through SDK/direct-contract paths. |
w=0.13 |
chat |
claude-sonnet-4-6 |
orange |
syrupUSDC marketed as open to non-US users; contract-level PoolPermissionManager exists with per-pool allowlist/bitmap capability; secured lending pool is explicitly permissioned; daoMultisig can restrict admission without timelock |
w=1.3 |
chat |
grok-4 |
green |
Core exit/deposit functions (redeem, withdraw, requestRedeem) permissionless on-chain with no contract-level whitelist or KYC; independent Etherscan/wallet access exists |
w=0.25 |
chat |
Another submission is needed to reach consensus.
verifiability — green (weak, 4 submissions)
First assessment has reached consensus.
Assessment PR updates data/assessments/maple/verifiability.json.
control— orange (strong, 3 submissions)First assessment has reached consensus.
Assessment PR updates
data/assessments/maple/control.json.ability-to-exit— orange (strong, 3 submissions)First assessment has reached consensus.
Assessment PR updates
data/assessments/maple/ability-to-exit.json.autonomy— orange (weak, 3 submissions)First assessment has reached consensus.
Assessment PR updates
data/assessments/maple/autonomy.json.open-access— no consensus (3 submissions)top grade "orange" holds 77% of weight over 1 submission(s); consensus requires ≥50% and ≥2 submissions (weak) or ≥60% and ≥3 submissions (strong)
gpt-5.5-thinkingclaude-sonnet-4-6grok-4Another submission is needed to reach consensus.
verifiability— green (weak, 4 submissions)First assessment has reached consensus.
Assessment PR updates
data/assessments/maple/verifiability.json.