You signed in with another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You signed out in another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You switched accounts on another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.Dismiss alert
Hi all,
Hoping to get some insights on the single point energy calculations using xtb --vea,
in a simple but not so simple scenario i have a
3-Nitrooxypropanol compound
i have done
xtb coord.xyz --opt && xtb xtbopt.xyz --vea
and got -0.5243
in any case i also tried
xtb coord.xyz --opt --chrg 0 --uhf 0
got -29.056665087868
xtb coord.xtbopt.xyz --chrg -1 --uhf 1
got -29.204404761940
the VEA using the two numbers above would give -0.14773
Why i went around exploring the --vea command is that, I have some cases of anions that i would like to test possible electron affinity with.
i do not think --vea was created to handle anions or charged molecules so i thought manually calculating my own VEA was the right thing to do.
Please advise where i went wrong or how i can go about looking at the --vea code itself which allows me to dig into the problem.
Kind regards,
hehe
xyz
15
O 2.81989 0.66868 -1.23933
C 2.36328 -0.00841 -0.07867
C 2.89300 0.69480 1.16032
C 4.41964 0.72042 1.19693
O 4.81624 1.37429 2.40046
N 6.22286 1.45715 2.53436
O 6.90884 0.94175 1.64999
O 6.56906 2.04290 3.55853
H 2.44078 0.21079 -2.01033
H 2.70867 -1.04632 -0.11816
H 1.26888 -0.00079 -0.07857
H 2.50849 0.20453 2.06255
H 2.52614 1.72852 1.18910
H 4.80498 1.26978 0.32969
H 4.79805 -0.30928 1.18622
xtbopt.xyz
15
energy: -29.056665087868 gnorm: 0.000603214985 xtb: 6.6.1 (8d0f1dd)
O 2.81496197321764 0.69241266693560 -1.21095711617680
C 2.36190425387697 -0.00661636698129 -0.07384977539772
C 2.89260860528217 0.70105022874473 1.16918548515873
C 4.41495445122677 0.69358944498075 1.17590822612323
O 4.84141080176158 1.36825937201962 2.35090788730548
N 6.21038845277978 1.46499117246393 2.53592159807743
O 6.89885505349059 0.97299649619334 1.70318685855331
O 6.51457482585646 2.03579708341238 3.52543216468961
H 2.46707272546720 0.27459020109305 -2.00487559434615
H 2.72135832907211 -1.04592545590562 -0.09242762693038
H 1.26396078491741 -0.01944490005444 -0.03826837331145
H 2.51777448532717 0.20588253238533 2.06422503163623
H 2.54753433244872 1.73448336494963 1.16781687078930
H 4.79769555490892 1.20812166365710 0.28883083826693
H 4.80374537036651 -0.33137750389411 1.18205352556226
The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered:
Hi all,
Hoping to get some insights on the single point energy calculations using xtb --vea,
in a simple but not so simple scenario i have a
3-Nitrooxypropanol compound
i have done
xtb coord.xyz --opt && xtb xtbopt.xyz --vea
and got -0.5243
in any case i also tried
xtb coord.xyz --opt --chrg 0 --uhf 0
got -29.056665087868
xtb coord.xtbopt.xyz --chrg -1 --uhf 1
got -29.204404761940
the VEA using the two numbers above would give -0.14773
Why i went around exploring the --vea command is that, I have some cases of anions that i would like to test possible electron affinity with.
i do not think --vea was created to handle anions or charged molecules so i thought manually calculating my own VEA was the right thing to do.
Please advise where i went wrong or how i can go about looking at the --vea code itself which allows me to dig into the problem.
Kind regards,
hehe
xyz
15
O 2.81989 0.66868 -1.23933
C 2.36328 -0.00841 -0.07867
C 2.89300 0.69480 1.16032
C 4.41964 0.72042 1.19693
O 4.81624 1.37429 2.40046
N 6.22286 1.45715 2.53436
O 6.90884 0.94175 1.64999
O 6.56906 2.04290 3.55853
H 2.44078 0.21079 -2.01033
H 2.70867 -1.04632 -0.11816
H 1.26888 -0.00079 -0.07857
H 2.50849 0.20453 2.06255
H 2.52614 1.72852 1.18910
H 4.80498 1.26978 0.32969
H 4.79805 -0.30928 1.18622
xtbopt.xyz
15
energy: -29.056665087868 gnorm: 0.000603214985 xtb: 6.6.1 (8d0f1dd)
O 2.81496197321764 0.69241266693560 -1.21095711617680
C 2.36190425387697 -0.00661636698129 -0.07384977539772
C 2.89260860528217 0.70105022874473 1.16918548515873
C 4.41495445122677 0.69358944498075 1.17590822612323
O 4.84141080176158 1.36825937201962 2.35090788730548
N 6.21038845277978 1.46499117246393 2.53592159807743
O 6.89885505349059 0.97299649619334 1.70318685855331
O 6.51457482585646 2.03579708341238 3.52543216468961
H 2.46707272546720 0.27459020109305 -2.00487559434615
H 2.72135832907211 -1.04592545590562 -0.09242762693038
H 1.26396078491741 -0.01944490005444 -0.03826837331145
H 2.51777448532717 0.20588253238533 2.06422503163623
H 2.54753433244872 1.73448336494963 1.16781687078930
H 4.79769555490892 1.20812166365710 0.28883083826693
H 4.80374537036651 -0.33137750389411 1.18205352556226
The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered: