Skip to content

flagging divergences between multiple hands of the same manuscript #270

@matteodifranco

Description

@matteodifranco

The second or third hands of the witnesses are encoded as hand as well as wit within the manuscript description, so that:

<witness xml:id="R" corresp="#R.hand.1">R
[...]
    <physDesc>
        <handDesc hands="2">
            <handNote xml:id="R.hand.1">First hand before correction</handNote>
            <handNote xml:id="R.hand.2">Second hand</handNote>
        </handDesc>
    </physDesc>
[...]
    <listWit>
        <witness xml:id="R.2" corresp="#R.hand.2">
            <label>R<hi rend="sup">2</hi></label>
        </witness>
        <witness xml:id="R.3" corresp="#R.hand.3">
            <label>R<hi rend="sup">3</hi></label>
        </witness>
    </listWit>
</witness>

This should be treated in the same way as families that include multiple witnesses.

In the collation visualization, when the second hand differs from the first, only the reading of the first hand is displayed, as in the following example:
R has γῆ, R² has γ’ ἡ as in the text

<app from="#Cyzicus-09-20" to="#Cyzicus-09-21">
    <lem wit="#O #R.2" exclude="#R">γ’ ἡ</lem>
    <rdg wit="#R #V #F #I #K #Pa #VaBo #D #U #Ab #T #Upp #Mq241 #Vat931
        #Iunt #Steph #Jebb #Dindorf" exclude="#R.2" type="associative" cause="diction">γῆ
        <note>add. in mg VaBo</note>
    </rdg>
    <rdg wit="#Vat932" type="lectio.sing" cause="diction">θ’ ἡ</rdg>
    <rdg wit="#Cs" type="lectio.sing" cause="omission"/>
</app>

Image

The screen also displays the issue of lemma repetition noted in #269.

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

No one assigned

    Labels

    bugSomething isn't working

    Type

    No type

    Projects

    No projects

    Milestone

    No milestone

    Relationships

    None yet

    Development

    No branches or pull requests

    Issue actions