Skip to content

SUBSTACK_GRADUATION.md

Latest commit

 

History

History
109 lines (74 loc) · 3.51 KB

SUBSTACK_GRADUATION.md

File metadata and controls

109 lines (74 loc) · 3.51 KB
Raw

🌱 Substack Evolution & Graduation System

Meritocious is built to let ideas evolve organically. Substacks don’t start as gated communities—they emerge naturally from meaningful patterns of discussion. This document outlines how tags evolve into Auto-Beta Substacks, and how the community votes to graduate them into full substacks.

🔁 Substack Lifecycle Overview

[Tag] → [Auto-Beta Substack] → [Graduation Vote] → [Permanent Substack]
                                  ↓
                         [Stays in Beta] or [Archived]

🧬 Phase 1: Tag Phase (Proto-Substack)

Any post can use tags. Some tags, over time, become strong enough to suggest a new thematic space is emerging.

📈 Promotion Criteria:

A tag becomes an Auto-Beta Substack when it meets all of these:

  • ✅ At least 10 unique posts using the tag
  • ✅ An average merit score ≥ 7.0 across those posts
  • ✅ At least 5 distinct contributors
  • ✅ Posts using the tag appear in 2 or more existing substacks

🚧 Phase 2: Auto-Beta Substack

When the threshold is reached, the system automatically creates a Beta Substack with:

  • A generated title and description based on post clustering
  • A collection of existing posts tagged accordingly
  • A listing in the UI under the section: “🌱 Growing Ideas”
  • A basic "beta" status badge in the header

✍️ Community Editing:

Contributors can propose:

  • Substack mission statement
  • Logo/icon
  • Tag refinements or splits

🗳️ Phase 3: Graduation Vote

After 30 days of activity (or other configurable period), the substack becomes eligible for graduation.

🎓 Graduation Requirements:

  • 🧠 20+ total posts in the Substack
  • 🌟 100+ cumulative merit score
  • 👥 At least 10 unique contributors
  • 📜 A community-drafted mission statement is submitted

🗳️ Voting Process:

  • Voting is open to users with merit score ≥ 50

  • 3 options:

    • ✅ Graduate to permanent Substack
    • 🧪 Stay in Beta (needs more time)
    • 🚫 Merge with or deprecate (too niche or redundant)

  • Passing Threshold:

    • ≥ 75% approval from 20+ eligible voters

💤 If It Doesn’t Graduate

If the vote fails:

  • It remains in beta and can be retried later
  • If no new posts in 60 days, it is auto-archived
    • Still viewable
    • Can be revived if interest resurges

🧱 Design Goals

  • 🌿 Organic Growth – Communities emerge naturally from participation
  • 🧭 Democratic Control – Users with high-merit reputations shape the ecosystem
  • 🧠 Semantic Cohesion – Prevents topic fragmentation and echo chambers
  • 📊 LLM-Friendly Architecture – Works with vector-based clustering and ranking

🧩 Future Features (Optional)

  • “📈 Trending Tags” area for watching potential beta candidates
  • Substack lineage metadata:
    • forked_from: Tech + Society
    • origin_tag: "AI in Agriculture"
  • Visual Substack Graph view for navigating forks, merges, and evolutions

🧠 Example Scenario

The tag #AI in Agriculture appears in 24 posts across 3 substacks, with a 7.9 average merit. 12 unique contributors have used it.
The system automatically promotes it to a Beta Substack called “AI in Agriculture”.
After a month of high activity, the community votes 84% in favor of graduation.
It becomes a permanent part of the Meritocious idea ecosystem.

Ideas evolve. So should the spaces we use to explore them.