2024-06-30-hanneke24b.md

title	section	abstract	layout	series	publisher	issn	id	month	tex_title	firstpage	lastpage	page	order	cycles	bibtex_author	author	date	address	container-title	volume	genre	issued	pdf	extras
List Sample Compression and Uniform Convergence	Original Papers	List learning is a variant of supervised classification where the learner outputs multiple plausible labels for each instance rather than just one. We investigate classical principles related to generalization within the context of list learning. Our primary goal is to determine whether classical principles in the PAC setting retain their applicability in the domain of list PAC learning. We focus on uniform convergence (which is the basis of Empirical Risk Minimization) and on sample compression (which is a powerful manifestation of Occam’s Razor). In classical PAC learning, both uniform convergence and sample compression satisfy a form of ‘completeness’: whenever a class is learnable, it can also be learned by a learning rule that adheres to these principles. We ask whether the same completeness holds true in the list learning setting. We show that uniform convergence remains equivalent to learnability in the list PAC learning setting. In contrast, our findings reveal surprising results regarding sample compression: we prove that when the label space is $Y=\{0,1,2\}$, then there are 2-list-learnable classes that cannot be compressed. This refutes the list version of the sample compression conjecture by Littlestone and Warmuth in 1986. We prove an even stronger impossibility result, showing that there are $2$-list-learnable classes that cannot be compressed even when the reconstructed function can work with lists of arbitrarily large size. We prove a similar result for (1-list) PAC learnable classes when the label space is unbounded.	inproceedings	Proceedings of Machine Learning Research	PMLR	2640-3498	hanneke24b	0	List Sample Compression and Uniform Convergence	2360	2388	2360-2388	2360	false	Hanneke, Steve and Moran, Shay and Tom, Waknine	given family Steve Hanneke given family Shay Moran given family Waknine Tom	2024-06-30		Proceedings of Thirty Seventh Conference on Learning Theory	247	inproceedings	date-parts 2024 6 30	https://proceedings.mlr.press/v247/hanneke24b/hanneke24b.pdf