2024-06-30-brandenberger24a.md

title	section	abstract	layout	series	publisher	issn	id	month	tex_title	firstpage	lastpage	page	order	cycles	bibtex_author	author	date	address	container-title	volume	genre	issued	pdf	extras
Errors are Robustly Tamed in Cumulative Knowledge Processes	Original Papers	We study processes of societal knowledge accumulation, where the validity of a new unit of knowledge depends both on the correctness of its derivation and on the validity of the units it depends on. A fundamental question in this setting is: If a constant fraction of the new derivations is wrong, can investing a constant fraction, bounded away from one, of effort ensure that a constant fraction of knowledge in society is valid? Ben-Eliezer, Mikulincer, Mossel, and Sudan (ITCS 2023) introduced a concrete probabilistic model to analyze such questions and showed an affirmative answer to this question. Their study, however, focuses on the simple case where each new unit depends on just one existing unit, and units attach according to a {\em preferential attachment rule}. In this work, we consider much more general families of cumulative knowledge processes, where new units may attach according to varied attachment mechanisms and depend on multiple existing units. We also allow a (random) fraction of insertions of adversarial nodes. We give a robust affirmative answer to the above question by showing that for \textit{all} of these models, as long as many of the units follow simple heuristics for checking a bounded number of units they depend on, all errors will be eventually eliminated. Our results indicate that preserving the quality of large interdependent collections of units of knowledge is feasible, as long as careful but not too costly checks are performed when new units are derived/deposited.	inproceedings	Proceedings of Machine Learning Research	PMLR	2640-3498	brandenberger24a	0	Errors are Robustly Tamed in Cumulative Knowledge Processes	630	631	630-631	630	false	Brandenberger, Anna and Marcussen, Cassandra and Mossel, Elchanan and Sudan, Madhu	given family Anna Brandenberger given family Cassandra Marcussen given family Elchanan Mossel given family Madhu Sudan	2024-06-30		Proceedings of Thirty Seventh Conference on Learning Theory	247	inproceedings	date-parts 2024 6 30	https://proceedings.mlr.press/v247/brandenberger24a/brandenberger24a.pdf