diff --git a/.zenodo.json b/.zenodo.json index 1a65e0d..3b51095 100644 --- a/.zenodo.json +++ b/.zenodo.json @@ -2,9 +2,9 @@ "title": "The Minority Prophet Property: Copy-Invariant Evidence Aggregation in Rooted Claim Graphs", "upload_type": "publication", "publication_type": "preprint", - "publication_date": "2026-08-16", - "version": "1.1.0", - "description": "A peer-review candidate establishing conditional copy-invariance and root-margin sensitivity results for evidence aggregation over finite rooted claim graphs, with Lean-checked proofs and preregistered bounded validation.", + "publication_date": "2026-08-18", + "version": "1.2.0", + "description": "A peer-review candidate establishing conditional copy-invariance and root-margin sensitivity results for evidence aggregation over finite rooted claim graphs, with Lean-checked proofs and preregistered bounded validation. v1.2.0 adds one scope limitation: the aggregator answers a symmetric question and does not decide universal or existential claims. No result, proof, or validation number of v1.1.0 is retracted.", "creators": [ { "name": "He, James Siyuan" @@ -24,6 +24,11 @@ { "identifier": "https://github.com/Silentpartnercoding/minority-prophet", "relation": "isSupplementTo" + }, + { + "identifier": "10.5281/zenodo.21965713", + "relation": "isNewVersionOf", + "scheme": "doi" } ] } diff --git a/output/pdf/minority-prophet-peer-review-v1.1.0.pdf b/output/pdf/minority-prophet-peer-review-v1.1.0.pdf index 4675023..7e6e08c 100644 Binary files a/output/pdf/minority-prophet-peer-review-v1.1.0.pdf and b/output/pdf/minority-prophet-peer-review-v1.1.0.pdf differ diff --git a/papers/peer-review/ARCHIVAL-INTEGRITY.md b/papers/peer-review/ARCHIVAL-INTEGRITY.md index 40bf9dd..95e7476 100644 --- a/papers/peer-review/ARCHIVAL-INTEGRITY.md +++ b/papers/peer-review/ARCHIVAL-INTEGRITY.md @@ -44,7 +44,42 @@ File minority-prophet-peer-review-v1.2.0.pdf DOI not yet assigned; no v1.2.0 deposit exists ``` -## Open item for the owner: the tracked v1.1.0 PDF is not the deposited one +## RESOLVED: the tracked v1.1.0 artifacts are now the deposited ones + +The v1.1.0 slot holds exactly what the v1.1.0 DOI resolves to. Both files were +restored from their published state, and the restoration was **verified, not +asserted**: + +```text +manuscript restored from tag paper-v1.1.0 + sha256 bffb546cfc8375c94fd64017f567d1708adc3df8eaeff4bd669c6dabce056998 +PDF downloaded from the Zenodo deposit + sha256 10413b41a2e87a527e2f01a29ed0cdfe17245a61eb0d9a6ce0bf334ca096d3da +rebuild building the restored manuscript on a different machine reproduces + the deposited PDF BYTE-FOR-BYTE, same sha256 10413b41... +``` + +That third line is the one that matters. It shows the restoration is correct, +that the ReportLab build is deterministic across machines, and that the +version-derived build change introduced with v1.2.0 does **not** disturb the +reproduction of v1.1.0 — a hardcoded version string would have produced a +different PDF here and the check would have failed. + +The DOI-bearing text that had drifted into the v1.1.0 slot now lives where it +belongs, in **v1.2.0**. The previously recorded `bb948d25…` regeneration is +superseded and is not tracked. + +### The problem this closes, kept visible + +> A reader of the repository's `v1.1.0` PDF was not reading the artifact the +> `v1.1.0` DOI resolved to. + +The cause was benign and worth naming: the DOI was assigned *after* the artifact +was frozen, and the natural repair — regenerate the PDF with the DOI in it — was +applied to the version slot that must not change. The correct home for a +post-publication correction is the next version, never the published one. + +## Superseded: open item for the owner (retained) The repository's tracked `output/pdf/minority-prophet-peer-review-v1.1.0.pdf` hashes to `bb948d25…` — the DOI-bearing regeneration. The **Zenodo deposit** diff --git a/papers/peer-review/minority-prophet-peer-review-v1.1.0.md b/papers/peer-review/minority-prophet-peer-review-v1.1.0.md index 26b1e6b..5afcc88 100644 --- a/papers/peer-review/minority-prophet-peer-review-v1.1.0.md +++ b/papers/peer-review/minority-prophet-peer-review-v1.1.0.md @@ -3,7 +3,7 @@ **James Siyuan He** Preprint v1.1.0; not peer reviewed, 16 August 2026 Correspondence: https://github.com/Silentpartnercoding -Archival DOI: https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.21965713 +Archival DOI: not yet assigned ## Abstract @@ -219,7 +219,7 @@ In a finite binary rooted-claim graph, counting declared roots rather than claim ## Data and code availability -All manuscript source, formal definitions and proofs, validation registrations, reference implementations, adverse findings, and result records are publicly available at https://github.com/Silentpartnercoding/minority-prophet. The reviewed source and PDF are fixed by the immutable `paper-v1.1.0` release tag. The archival preprint record, including the PDF and release archive, is available at https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.21965713. +All manuscript source, formal definitions and proofs, validation registrations, reference implementations, adverse findings, and result records are publicly available at https://github.com/Silentpartnercoding/minority-prophet. The peer-review candidate is versioned in `papers/peer-review/`. An immutable release tag and archival DOI will be assigned only after maintainer approval of the candidate; the absence of an assigned DOI does not affect review of the repository record. ## Ethics statement