diff --git a/docs/RECHECK-QUEUE.md b/docs/RECHECK-QUEUE.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000..918004f --- /dev/null +++ b/docs/RECHECK-QUEUE.md @@ -0,0 +1,39 @@ +# Recheck Queue + +Open Problem Lab should have a visible queue for artifacts that are not wrong, but are not strong enough to remain load-bearing without another pass. + +## Purpose + +The recheck queue captures work that needs a second look because of weak evidence, old sources, unclear boundaries, reviewer concerns, field uncertainty, or changing context. + +It is a routing mechanism, not a rejection mechanism. + +## Queue entry + +```markdown +## RQ-YYYY-NNN — Short name + +**Artifact:** Link to claim, evidence record, issue, PR, or problem-pack section. + +**Reason for recheck:** One paragraph. + +**Trigger:** Source age, field report, reviewer concern, dataset update, method concern, or status change. + +**Needed reviewer:** general | evidence | domain | quantitative | field | maintainer. + +**Smallest useful check:** The next action that would reduce uncertainty. + +**Decision after check:** keep | bound | dispute | archive | escalate. +``` + +## Reviewer guidance + +A reviewer should use the queue when work is promising but not ready to carry its current confidence level. + +## Agent guidance + +Agents should inspect the queue before proposing new work. A queued artifact is often the best place to make a valuable contribution. + +## Acceptance test + +A queue entry is useful when another contributor can immediately see what to check, why it matters, and how the result would change repository status.