-
Notifications
You must be signed in to change notification settings - Fork 13
Description
Describe the bug
A clear and concise description of what the bug is.
😆
Ok, this one is gross: With the fix in #49, a direct
dependency held on a parent module that was also held on a child module would be correctly placed into the common
dependency set because it is needed directly by the parent
. This is, unfortunately, only a first-order fix since this same situation can occur when the dependency is needed by a Third Party dependency held directly by the parent rather than a local child sub-module.
This is only a problem if the requirements
list given to parse_requirements
includes the transitive dependency that is only used by the Third Party dependency and is NOT used anywhere inside of the local library. This is a very unlikely circumstance, but it could conceivably arise if the Third party dependency has an open version range for the transitive dependency, but the local library needs to pin that version for some valid reason (like a security patch)..
Platform
Please provide details about the environment you are using, including the following:
- Interpreter version:
- Library version:
Sample Code
def test_nested_deps():
"""Make sure that direct depencencies show up in requirements
for nested modules
"""
requirements, extras_require = parse_requirements(
["sample_lib", "PyYaml", "alchemy-logging"],
"direct_dep_nested",
["direct_dep_nested.nested", "direct_dep_nested.nested2"]
)
Expected behavior
The PyYaml
dependency should be in the common requirements
because it's needed transitively by sample_lib
which is needed directly by the top-level direct_dep_nested
module.
assert requirements == sorted(["alchemy-logging", "sample_lib"])
assert extras_require == {
"all": sorted(["sample_lib", "PyYaml", "alchemy-logging", "PyYaml"]),
"direct_dep_nested.nested": [],
"direct_dep_nested.nested2": [],
}
Observed behavior
The PyYaml
dependency is placed into the extras for direct_dep_nested.nested
because it's held as an extra
set and PyYaml
is not allocated as a direct
dependency of the top-level direct_dep_nested
module.
assert requirements == sorted(["alchemy-logging", "sample_lib"])
assert extras_require == {
"all": sorted(["sample_lib", "PyYaml", "alchemy-logging"]),
"direct_dep_nested.nested": ["PyYaml"],
"direct_dep_nested.nested2": [],
}
Additional context
Discovered when trying to write a test case for #53 with @prashantgupta24